Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Charles Dodgson's Song" by Randall Jarrell presents a collage of historical and intellectual figures, each depicted in moments that reflect their inner struggles and eccentricities. The poem juxtaposes the achievements and turmoil of these figures, creating a tapestry that explores the tension between rational thought and emotional experience.

The poem opens with the line "The band played Idomeneo," referencing Mozart's opera, a piece often associated with complex human emotions and dramatic narratives. This sets the tone for the exploration of the intricate and often contradictory nature of human existence. The mention of "A child's felicity / Held Stendhal, sitting with the Empress Eugenie on his fat knee" juxtaposes the innocence and joy of a child with the worldly and perhaps burdensome presence of Stendhal, the famed French writer known for his psychological insights and romanticism. The image of Stendhal with Empress Eugenie, a symbol of political and social power, suggests a complex interplay of personal contentment and societal expectations.

The poem then shifts to James Clerk Maxwell, a renowned physicist whose work on electromagnetism laid the groundwork for much of modern physics. "Clerk Maxwell's demon was possessed; / He lay for half his days / And never moved a single molecule." This reference to Maxwell's thought experiment, involving a demon that could violate the second law of thermodynamics, symbolizes the relentless pursuit of knowledge and the isolation that can accompany intellectual endeavors. Maxwell's immobilized state reflects the paradox of intense mental activity paired with physical inertia.

John Stuart Mill, another key figure, is portrayed "haunted by the silent face / Of Bentham-it was made of wax." Mill, a philosopher and economist, is depicted here struggling with the legacy of Jeremy Bentham, the founder of utilitarianism. The waxen face symbolizes the rigidity and lifelessness of Bentham's utilitarian philosophy, which Mill grappled with throughout his life. The line "Read Wordsworth, and at last could weep" captures Mill's eventual emotional release through poetry, highlighting the conflict between rationalism and emotional expression.

The speaker's personal search for love leads to an ironic discovery: "I sought for love, and found it in girls' gloves: / There's none outside, you know." This line suggests a disillusionment with the external world's capacity to provide genuine affection, finding instead a superficial and material substitute. The gloves symbolize the elusive nature of true connection and the speaker's retreat into trivial comforts.

The poem's closing lines introduce Charles Darwin and his son, adding a touch of dark humor and existential reflection. "That bird's dead," remarks Darwin's son, to which Darwin, dejectedly, responds by "broke his spear, looked deep / Into the Cause of things: but it was only / A hippopotamus asleep." This scene encapsulates the absurdity and anticlimax often found in the search for profound truths. Darwin, the great naturalist who unveiled the theory of evolution, is here rendered impotent and disillusioned, finding not a grand revelation but a mundane reality.

"Charles Dodgson's Song" weaves together these disparate figures and moments to illustrate the complexities of intellectual pursuit and human emotion. Each character's struggle with their respective fields of study and personal demons underscores the poem's central theme: the search for meaning in a world that often offers only partial answers and fleeting glimpses of understanding. Jarrell's use of historical and literary references enriches the poem, inviting readers to reflect on the interplay between thought, feeling, and the human condition. Through its rich tapestry of imagery and allusion, the poem captures the enduring quest for knowledge and the bittersweet recognition of its limits.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...