Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Derek Mahon’s "Afterlives" is a meditation on displacement, privilege, and the evolving nature of home. The poem consists of two distinct sections, both of which explore the tensions between memory and reality, personal identity and historical change. Through a reflective, at times self-critical, voice, Mahon examines the contrast between an idealized vision of progress and the harsher truths of war, sectarianism, and exile.

The first section begins with a moment of awakening: “I wake in a dark flat / To the soft roar of the world.” The phrase “soft roar” immediately establishes the paradoxical atmosphere of modern life—simultaneously tranquil and chaotic. The speaker looks out over London, a city bathed in “morning light,” appearing fresh and full of possibility. This optimism is initially reinforced by the reference to “bright / Reason on which we rely / For the long-term solutions.” Mahon’s language suggests faith in rationality and progress, particularly in overcoming the conflicts that have shaped history. However, this faith is soon challenged by the more immediate realities of violence: “The orators yap, and guns / Go off in a back street.” This sudden intrusion of brutality contrasts with the earlier idealism, foreshadowing the deeper self-doubt that emerges later in the poem.

The poem’s most striking moment of self-critique comes in the final stanza of the first section: “What middle-class shits we are / To imagine for one second / That our privileged ideals / Are divine wisdom.” This abrupt shift in tone marks a moment of deep reckoning. Mahon confronts the illusion that intellectuals and poets—perhaps including himself—possess a superior moral vision. The “privileged ideals” of enlightenment and reason are contrasted with the enduring religious faith of those “dim / Forms that kneel at noon / In the city not ourselves.” These lines suggest an awareness that those who struggle daily with violence and hardship may possess a wisdom that the poet’s class overlooks. The reference to religious devotion, though possibly critical, also acknowledges a form of resilience that contrasts with detached, intellectualized notions of progress.

The second section of the poem shifts to a more personal mode, as the speaker describes his return to Belfast after years away. The sea voyage evokes both nostalgia and uncertainty: “I am going home by sea / For the first time in years.” The setting of the dark deck, the distant guitar music, and the gull dreaming at the masthead create a mood of contemplation. This maritime passage functions as a liminal space—neither fully home nor fully away—mirroring the poet’s conflicted relationship with his place of origin.

Upon arrival, the speaker encounters a city transformed by war: “At dawn the ship trembles, turns / In a wide arc to back / Shuddering up the grey lough.” The imagery of trembling and shuddering conveys a sense of foreboding, as if the ship itself reacts to the trauma of the land it approaches. Belfast, once familiar, is now unrecognizable: “I scarcely recognize / The places I grew up in, / The faces that try to explain.” The phrase “try to explain” suggests an emotional and communicative distance—those who remained have experienced war firsthand, while the speaker has been absent. His return is not just a homecoming but an encounter with a reality he has not fully lived through.

The final stanza deepens this sense of alienation. The hills above Belfast remain unchanged—an enduring feature of the landscape, indifferent to human suffering. Yet this constancy only highlights the speaker’s own displacement. The concluding lines—“Perhaps if I’d stayed behind / And lived it bomb by bomb / I might have grown up at last / And learnt what is meant by home”—convey a profound ambivalence. The phrase “lived it bomb by bomb” suggests that true understanding of Belfast’s struggles comes only through direct experience of its violence. By leaving, the speaker has gained distance but also lost a crucial connection to his homeland. The implication is that his understanding of home is incomplete, filtered through memory rather than lived reality.

Mahon’s style in "Afterlives" is understated yet deeply resonant. His use of enjambment propels the poem forward, mimicking the flow of thought and the journey from London to Belfast. The shifts between broad historical concerns and personal reflection reinforce the poem’s thematic depth. Ultimately, "Afterlives" is not just about returning home—it is about the impossibility of fully returning, about the ways in which both places and people change, and about the lingering question of what it truly means to belong.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...