Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"The Charge of the Dog Brigade" by Andrew Motion offers a unique lens through which to view the famous military blunder known as the Charge of the Light Brigade during the Crimean War. In this reimagining, Motion focuses not on the six hundred soldiers but on a "pampered fox terrier" who joins the charge. This offbeat perspective serves as an imaginative device to scrutinize heroism, humanity, and the myths that are often built around historical events.

The original Charge of the Light Brigade has long been immortalized through Alfred Lord Tennyson's poem, which celebrated the unquestioning valor of the soldiers. While Tennyson's work elevated the "noble six hundred" to almost mythical status, Motion's version humanizes them. These are men who enjoy "drinking until one collapsed" and who engage in mindless chatter, repeating a "farmyard of noises" about various nationalities and women. By presenting this angle, Motion subverts the established narrative, asking us to consider the flaws and ordinary tendencies of the men who partook in the charge.

The fox terrier serves as a narrative device to underscore the complexity of the event. The dog is an innocent, devoid of the soldiers' pretensions or understanding of the geopolitical conflict they are a part of. He joins the charge thinking "that this was the point of his madcap existence," which could mirror the men's own false sense of purpose and destiny. The terrier is also used to bring in the sensory elements of the charge-the "firecracker racket," the "po-faced hilarious crash," and the "antics of horses"-which serve to heighten the absurdity of the event. These sensory elements counterbalance the traditional, solemn portrayal of the charge, breathing life into its historical caricature.

Stylistically, Motion employs long, winding sentences that serve to capture the chaos and momentum of the charge. The cadence of the poem reflects the frenetic energy of both men and dog charging into the "Valley of Death." The poem's language is rich and vibrant, combining colloquial expressions with more formal elements, thereby creating a vivid tapestry that is both respectful and irreverent.

The poem also functions as a meta-commentary on the role of poets and poetry in shaping national memory and myth. Motion, like Tennyson before him, held the position of British Poet Laureate, a role often linked with capturing the national mood or commemorating significant events. His reinterpretation asks us to question how historical events are mythologized, urging a more complex understanding that incorporates multiple perspectives, including those from the fringes-like a naive fox terrier.

In conclusion, Andrew Motion's "The Charge of the Dog Brigade" is a brilliant reimagining that uses humor, irreverence, and poignant human details to probe the myth of the Charge of the Light Brigade. While paying homage to the event and the men who were a part of it, the poem also challenges us to reevaluate the simplistic narratives that are often constructed around historical events, urging us toward a more nuanced understanding.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...