Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Paul Muldoon's "The More a Man Has the More a Man Wants" is a sprawling, fragmented narrative that delves into the chaotic and absurd world of a character named Gallogly. The poem is steeped in the surreal, blending elements of dark humor, violence, and historical allusion, all while maintaining a sense of disorientation that mirrors the troubled and divided land of Northern Ireland. The title, which suggests an exploration of greed or desire, quickly subverts expectations, instead plunging the reader into a whirlwind of disconnected yet vividly detailed scenes that challenge traditional narrative coherence.

Muldoon's language is a significant feature of this poem, characterized by its dense and often cryptic nature. The poem opens with Gallogly waking to "the yawn of brakes, / the snore of a diesel engine." This personification of machinery establishes an uneasy tone, as if the inanimate world is complicit in the unfolding chaos. The subsequent line, "Gone. All she left / is a froth of bra and panties," introduces a sense of abandonment and loss, but it is delivered with a casual, almost dismissive tone that pervades much of the poem. Muldoon’s use of language here is both vivid and detached, creating a tension between the lurid imagery and the cool, observational style in which it is presented.

The structure of the poem is non-linear, composed of a series of vignettes that seem to leap from one scene to the next with little concern for narrative continuity. This disjointedness reflects the fragmented nature of Gallogly’s world, where events and characters are interconnected in ways that are often unclear. The scenes are populated with a wide array of characters, from "six, maybe seven, skinheads" sniffing glue around a fire to a "U.D.R. corporal" caught in the crossfire of a conflict. Each scene is rich with detail, yet the connections between them are elusive, forcing the reader to piece together meaning from the shards of narrative provided.

Muldoon’s references to various cultural and historical figures add layers of complexity to the poem. Gallogly is seen through the lens of historical and literary allusions, from his comparison to "David Balfour in Kidnapped" to the invocation of figures like Wolfe Tone and Thomas Meagher. These references create a tapestry of associations, linking Gallogly’s personal turmoil to broader historical and cultural struggles. The allusions serve to both ground the poem in a specific cultural context and to destabilize it, as they introduce elements of irony and ambiguity that further complicate the reader’s understanding.

The poem’s themes of violence, identity, and displacement are explored through Gallogly’s interactions with his environment and the people around him. The recurrent motif of disguise and transformation—whether it’s Gallogly donning a "candy-stripe king-size sheet" or the police searching for him in vain—suggests a fluidity of identity that mirrors the shifting political and social landscape of Northern Ireland. The violence that pervades the poem is both physical and psychological, with scenes of bloodshed juxtaposed against moments of absurdity, such as Gallogly "munching through a Beauty of Bath" apple. This blend of the grotesque and the banal highlights the surreal nature of life in a conflict zone, where the boundaries between reality and absurdity are constantly blurred.

In conclusion, "The More a Man Has the More a Man Wants" is a complex, multilayered poem that resists easy interpretation. Muldoon’s use of fragmented narrative, rich imagery, and allusive language creates a disorienting yet compelling exploration of a world marked by violence, loss, and the search for meaning in chaos. The poem’s title, which initially seems to promise a meditation on desire, ultimately serves as a sardonic commentary on the futility of seeking coherence in a world that defies understanding. Through Gallogly’s journey, Muldoon invites the reader to confront the bewildering nature of existence, where the more one seeks to grasp, the more elusive meaning becomes.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...