Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Inside Dachau" by Sherman Alexie is a multi-faceted, profound poem that not only interrogates the memory of Dachau, a concentration camp during World War II, but also serves as an exposition of memory, grief, and collective tragedy. With intricate attention to detail, Alexie explores the themes of culpability, remembrance, and parallel narratives, framing them within the context of the concentration camp Dachau, and drawing parallels to the Native American experience in the United States.

One of the most striking features of the poem is its complex structure. Divided into seven numbered sections, each with its own form, the poem adopts varied styles that parallel the shifting perspectives and emotional states of the speaker. For instance, the poem starts with a sestina in the first section, "big lies, small lies," exploring the emotions of the speaker who expects to feel "simple emotions: hate, anger, sorrow." This form, which is strict and organized, mirrors the expectation of an organized narrative around Dachau, one that is easily categorized as evil and thereby easily dismissed. As the poem progresses, however, the forms deviate from the strict sestina, reflecting the more complex, tangled feelings the speaker has after visiting the camp.

The poem also delves into themes of collective guilt and culpability. In the section titled "big lies, small lies," Alexie recounts the speaker's expectation to squarely blame Munich, a short train ride away from Dachau. However, these expectations are dismantled as the speaker confronts the complexity of culpability: "The poems still took their forms, but my earlier plans seemed so selfish." Furthermore, the speaker's German hosts highlight the hypocrisy of an American judging Germany for its past when America itself has its "death camps," referring to the subjugation and genocide of Native Americans.

Alexie tackles the theme of memory in the segment "history as the home movie," which opens and closes with the refrain "it begins and ends with ash," representing both the ash from concentration camps and the ash of Native American burning grounds. It asserts that the universal tendency to forget or selectively remember atrocities makes us all culpable in their perpetuation. This theme recurs in the section "commonly asked questions," which questions the motivations behind visiting a site like Dachau. Are we seeking an "apology" or simply a confrontation with historical horror?

Perhaps the most poignant section is "the American Indian Holocaust Museum," which directly juxtaposes the genocide of Jews during World War II with the massacre and disenfranchisement of Native Americans. Alexie positions these two tragedies as parallel narratives, both deserving of memory, grieving, and a permanent physical testament like a museum.

Alexie's style is richly layered, utilizing a blend of direct narration and allegorical elements. For example, the motif of "ash" recurs throughout the poem, symbolizing both the literal ash of concentration camps and the metaphorical ash of destroyed cultures and lives. His lines are taut and filled with palpable emotion, yet devoid of sentimentality.

"Inside Dachau" is a poem that resists easy categorization or facile interpretation. It demands that its readers wrestle with the complexities of history, memory, and moral culpability. It serves not just as a testament to the past, but also as a warning for the future-a reminder that horrors occur not just in far-off places and distant times, but here and now, within each of us. It holds up a mirror to society, forcing us to confront the ash that we, willingly or not, have had a hand in creating.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...