Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"In the Western Night: 3. Two Men" by Frank Bidart presents a stark contrast between self-awareness and self-deception, exploring the profound implications of these states on personal identity and relational dynamics. This poem, layered with Bidart's characteristic depth and intensity, delves into the essence of human consciousness, the hunger for emotional fulfillment, and the illusions we craft around our desires and fears. By juxtaposing two metaphorically rich images—the man who does not know himself and the man who futilely attempts to satiate his hunger with stone—the poem navigates the complex terrain of self-knowledge and the existential hunger that defines the human condition.

The poem opens by depicting a man out of touch with his inner life, whose actions betray emotions and desires he refuses to acknowledge. This man's inability to recognize his own truths renders him "STONE… NOT BREAD," a symbol of the emotional and spiritual sustenance he lacks. The repetition of "NOT BREAD" emphasizes the barrenness of his existence, deprived of the nourishment necessary for genuine human connection and growth. This figure, who "will SAY ANYTHING" and unknowingly lies to maintain his self-constructed narratives, embodies the peril of living detached from one's authentic self. The metaphor of stone underscores the cold, unyielding nature of his self-deception, highlighting the futility of seeking comfort or fulfillment in falsehoods.

Contrasting with this portrayal, the second part of the poem introduces the theme of insatiable hunger, a metaphor for the deep, often unacknowledged yearnings that drive human behavior. The man who "tries to feed his hunger / by gnawing stone" is labeled a "FOOL," not for the nature of his hunger, but for his misguided attempts to satisfy it through means that cannot possibly provide sustenance. This image resonates with the earlier depiction of self-deception, suggesting that both men are engaged in futile efforts to appease their inner voids, albeit in different manners. The poem thus explores the universal human experience of craving—whether for knowledge, love, or meaning—and the various ways we attempt, and often fail, to fulfill these cravings.

The "Epilogue: A Stanza from Horace" shifts the focus to the realm of dreams and pursuit, offering a poignant contrast to the earlier sections. This dreamlike pursuit, with its imagery of flight and elusiveness, encapsulates the longing and desperation that pervade the poem. The reference to Horace not only anchors the poem within a broader literary tradition but also deepens its exploration of desire and the pain of unattainable objectives. The fleeting nature of the pursued, whether in dreams or reality, mirrors the elusive satisfaction the earlier figures seek in their denial and misguided attempts at fulfillment.

"Two Men" is a meditation on the human condition, marked by a relentless quest for self-understanding and the search for something beyond the self to fill the voids within. Bidart's poem is a reflection on the ways in which individuals confront, or fail to confront, the truths of their existence. Through its vivid imagery and philosophical depth, the poem invites readers to consider the nature of their own hungers, the realities they may refuse to acknowledge, and the paths they choose in the pursuit of fulfillment. In doing so, Bidart crafts a narrative that is both a critique and a lament, a nuanced exploration of the complexities of self-awareness and the ceaseless yearning that drives the human spirit.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...