Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"A Conversation with Leonardo" by John Ciardi is a whimsical yet profound poem that imagines a nocturnal encounter between the narrator and Leonardo da Vinci, the Renaissance polymath whose quests for ideal proportion and understanding of the human form have left an indelible mark on art and science. The poem, through its playful yet insightful dialogue, explores themes of artistic ideals, the nature of human imperfection, and the evolution of aesthetic values over time.

Set against the backdrop of a stifling, powerless night, the poem begins with the narrator's discomfort, amplified by the failure of the air conditioner and the sealed state of the windows. In this setting of physical discomfort and vulnerability, Leonardo appears, as if conjured from the depths of history, to engage in a dialogue about the human form, artistic representation, and philosophical ideals.

Leonardo's attempt to sketch the narrator, to fit his hands, feet, and head into a "turned ratio," evokes his famous Vitruvian Man, symbolizing the Renaissance's quest for harmony, proportion, and the integration of humanist and scientific inquiry. However, the narrator quickly points out the futility of seeking ideal proportion in modern times, suggesting a disconnect between the Renaissance ideals and contemporary realities.

Leonardo's response, considering deformity as a valuable collector's item if it reveals "a memory of man," points to the Renaissance belief in the inherent value and dignity of human experience, even in imperfection. This perspective contrasts with the narrator's more cynical view, which sees contemporary humanity as removed from the absolutes and ideals that once defined artistic and philosophical endeavors.

The dialogue delves deeper into philosophical territory, referencing Praxiteles, an ancient Greek sculptor known for his lifelike representations, and moving through a critique of Platonic ideals. The narrator suggests that modern man is measured not by absolutes but by relativity, by comparisons within a "genre" or "school," implying a fragmentation of value and a departure from universal standards.

Leonardo's accusation of "absolute irrelevance" and the narrator's admission of "a reverence for what was never there" underscore the poem's exploration of the tension between the eternal pursuit of perfection and the acceptance of human limitation and imperfection. The reference to "God measures perfection and crock measures pot" further illustrates this dichotomy, suggesting that divine or absolute standards are unattainable, leaving humans to measure themselves by their own flawed creations.

The poem concludes with Leonardo expressing gratitude for having lived in a time when divine form and order were still revered, contrasting sharply with the narrator's implied disillusionment with the contemporary world's loss of absolutes and ideals.

"A Conversation with Leonardo" by John Ciardi offers a richly layered meditation on the enduring quest for beauty, truth, and proportion in art and life. Through its imaginative encounter between one of history's greatest minds and a modern interlocutor, the poem invites readers to reflect on the shifting sands of aesthetic and philosophical values, challenging us to find meaning and relevance in a world that has moved beyond the certainties of the past.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...