Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"A New Poem (For Jack Spicer)" by Robert Duncan is a meditation on the nature of poetry, engaging in a dialogue with the ideas presented by his contemporary and fellow poet, Jack Spicer. The poem is both a tribute and a philosophical exploration, reflecting on the metaphorical interpretations of what poetry constitutes and its intrinsic, often enigmatic power.

Duncan begins by presenting a series of metaphors to describe poetry: "What we call Poetry is the boat. / The first boat, the body—but it was a bed. / The bed, but it was a car." These shifting images suggest the fluidity and multifaceted nature of poetry, emphasizing its capacity to transform and encompass various forms of existence and experience. The boat, a classic symbol of journey and discovery, evolves into a bed—a place of rest and dreams, and then into a car—a modern symbol of movement and progress. This evolution reflects the dynamic and evolving nature of poetic expression and its capacity to carry us through different terrains of understanding and being.

The mention of the "driver or sandman, the boatman, the familiar stranger, first lover" introduces a figure who is central yet absent, an elusive guide or creator figure who shapes the journey but remains detached. This character represents the elusive essence of poetry itself—vital and influential yet not entirely graspable or present in a conventional sense.

Duncan then counters his own initial metaphor with a response, perhaps inspired by Spicer’s views, stating, "You are wrong. / What we call Poetry is the lake itself, the bewildering circling waterway." This shift from the boat to the lake suggests moving from viewing poetry as a vehicle or medium to seeing it as the very environment or realm in which we find ourselves immersed. The lake, with its depth and expansiveness, symbolizes the profound and often perplexing scope of poetry—encompassing and reflective, yet challenging to navigate.

The poem delves deeper into the philosophical implications of engaging with poetry, highlighting our complex relationship with it: "having our power in what we know nothing of, in this having neither father nor son, / our never having come into it, our never having left it." These lines touch on the timeless, almost ancestral connection we have with poetry, an art form that exists independently of our personal discoveries or creations.

The figure who "refuses to guide the boat but crosses and recrosses the heart" is portrayed as a master of moral and existential ambiguities—"Master he is of turning right and wrong." This description underscores the transformative power of poetry to challenge, provoke, and reinterpret our perceptions of truth and morality. Duncan acknowledges the difficulty in defining this figure, resisting the label of "Master of Truth" yet conceding his mastery in navigating the complex moral waters of human experience.

Finally, Duncan concludes that "The boat has its own light," a statement affirming the inherent value and self-sufficiency of poetry. This line encapsulates the poem's exploration of poetry as a self-enlightening journey, suggesting that poetry illuminates itself and the path for the reader or writer through its unique, inherent qualities.

Overall, "A New Poem (For Jack Spicer)" is a rich and layered discourse on the essence of poetry, presenting it as both a journey and a realm, a vehicle and a medium through which we explore and experience the depths of human consciousness and the complexities of existence. Duncan's poem itself mirrors the poetic exploration it describes—complex, multifaceted, and enlightening.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...