Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"And If He Had Been Wrong for Me" by Robert Duncan is a poignant meditation on memory, longing, and the emotional resonance of past relationships. Through evocative imagery and contemplative tones, Duncan explores the profound impact that a significant other can have, even if their presence in one's life might have been fraught with ambiguity or uncertainty.

The poem begins with an acknowledgment of the potential mismatch between the speaker and the man in question: "yet he was there, and all my thirst gathered in the thought of him that year." Despite any doubts about their compatibility, the speaker recognizes the undeniable influence and presence of this individual. The use of "thirst" metaphorically underscores a deep yearning and emotional necessity, suggesting a profound, almost vital need for this person's presence.

Duncan beautifully describes the man as "a tall liquid presence of the man, a river running in the sound of him," which further reinforces the idea of him being both a nourishing and overwhelming force in the speaker’s life. The imagery of the man as a river encapsulates both the sustaining and potentially destructive nature of water—invigorating yet capable of overwhelming. This depiction conveys the dynamic and powerful impact he had on the speaker's life, flowing through and shaping the emotional landscape.

The poem then shifts to a more serene and reflective imagery: "sun dazzle in the shallows, shadows in the pool beneath the rocks." These lines conjure visuals of light and darkness playing upon water, symbolizing the shifting perceptions and emotions in the speaker's reminiscence. The sunlight and shadows represent moments of clarity and obscurity within their relationship, moments that are both illuminating and difficult to fully discern.

Duncan delves deeper into the introspective journey with the lines, "It is a place of early lonely thought, impatient revery of a cool green." This suggests a contemplative solitude, a mental space where the speaker revisits past feelings and moments, colored by both tranquility and a restless yearning for understanding or resolution. The "cool green" evokes a sense of calm and refreshment, perhaps a mental oasis that the memory of this person provides amidst the turmoil of questioning what could have been.

The closing lines, "It is a glass of water ever just poured for me, a memory kept silent come to speak," beautifully encapsulate the essence of the poem. The glass of water—a simple, sustaining, and transparent element—symbolizes clarity, purity, and the essential nature of the memories and feelings associated with this person. The memory, once silent, now speaks, suggesting that these reflections bring new insights or emotional revelations that were not previously articulated.

Overall, "And If He Had Been Wrong for Me" by Robert Duncan is a lyrical exploration of the lingering impact of a relationship characterized by both doubt and undeniable significance. Through lush imagery and reflective tones, Duncan captures the complex interplay of memory, longing, and the transformative power of past connections that continue to shape our emotional landscapes, long after they have faded from our present lives.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...