Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Robert Frost’s poem “Leaves Compared With Flowers” delves into the comparative value of different parts of a tree, using this comparison as a metaphor for human preferences and perspectives on life. Through straightforward language and a contemplative tone, Frost explores themes of beauty, utility, and personal fulfillment.

The poem begins with a general statement about the qualities of a tree: “A tree’s leaves may be ever so good, / So may its bark, so may its wood.” Frost acknowledges the inherent goodness and utility of various parts of a tree, setting up a foundation for his subsequent argument. However, he immediately introduces a condition for achieving the more visible and celebrated aspects of a tree: “But unless you put the right thing to its root / It never will show much flower or fruit.” Here, Frost underscores the importance of proper nourishment and care for a tree to produce flowers and fruits, symbolizing the idea that effort and attention are required to achieve beauty and productivity.

Frost then shifts to a personal perspective, expressing a potential indifference to such outcomes: “But I may be one who does not care / Ever to have tree bloom or bear.” This admission reveals a preference for the simpler, more enduring aspects of the tree—its leaves and bark—over the more transient and ornamental flowers and fruits. The lines “Leaves for smooth and bark for rough, / Leaves and bark may be tree enough” further emphasize this point, suggesting that the fundamental, structural parts of the tree are sufficient for some.

The poet continues to reflect on the varying significance of tree blooms: “Some giant trees have bloom so small / They might as well have none at all.” This observation highlights the disparity in the visibility and impact of flowers among different trees, implying that not all displays of beauty are significant or necessary. Frost’s appreciation for less obvious forms of beauty and life becomes more evident as he mentions his later-life discovery: “Late in life I have come on fern. / Now lichens are due to have their turn.” The shift to ferns and lichens, plants that are often overlooked, suggests a mature recognition and appreciation for subtle and understated forms of life.

The poet then poses a question to others about the comparative beauty of flowers and leaves: “I bade men tell me which in brief, / Which is fairer, flower or leaf.” The response, or lack thereof, reveals a common inability to discern or appreciate the nuanced beauty of leaves: “They did not have the wit to say, / Leaves by night and flowers by day.” This line suggests that people often favor the more conspicuous beauty of flowers during the day, neglecting the quiet, enduring presence of leaves that become more prominent and appreciated at night.

Frost concludes the poem by reaffirming his personal preference: “Leaves and bark, leaves and bark, / To lean against and hear in the dark.” These lines convey a sense of comfort and solace found in the enduring and reliable parts of the tree. The final lines, “Petals I may have once pursued. / Leaves are all my darker mood,” encapsulate the poet’s journey from seeking the fleeting beauty of flowers to finding contentment in the lasting presence of leaves, reflecting a deeper, perhaps more melancholic, appreciation for the simple and constant elements of life.

“Leaves Compared With Flowers” is a contemplative poem that explores the differing values placed on various forms of beauty and utility in nature. Through his reflective and introspective language, Frost invites readers to consider the worth of subtle, enduring qualities over more obvious, temporary displays. The poem ultimately suggests that true appreciation and fulfillment may lie in recognizing and valuing the often-overlooked aspects of life.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...