Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Naomi Shihab Nye’s "Estate Sale: The Scrabble Game of a Dead Woman" captures the quiet devastation of sorting through a deceased person’s belongings, where the remnants of a life are reduced to objects priced and picked over by strangers. The poem’s central metaphor—the Scrabble game—suggests both the attempt to reconstruct meaning from scattered fragments and the arbitrary nature of what remains.

The poem begins with an aerial perspective, as if the speaker is hovering over the scene: "A crowd of strangers flies over your life / picking out landmarks." This imagery likens the estate sale attendees to birds scavenging through the deceased’s possessions, reducing the details of a life—*"stainless steel cake pan, jello mold, pastel box of thank you notes"—*to mere commodities. The list is deliberately mundane, highlighting the ordinary yet deeply personal artifacts left behind. The absurdity of valuing such things is emphasized when even "a 25-cent price tag" is affixed to a box of tissues in the bathroom, an almost comical yet deeply sad reduction of personal space into saleable goods.

Unlike the "buoyant women hired to coordinate this last event," the speaker is "a prowler, unable to smile back." This self-description suggests a discomfort with the detachment of those facilitating the sale, as if their cheerfulness contrasts too starkly with the gravity of what is being lost. The speaker's unease grows when encountering a telephone with "scrawled number of SON DAVID EVANS taped to the side," an object that embodies hope and expectation. The handwritten name suggests the deceased intended for this information to be used, possibly in emergencies or for connection. The speaker’s thought—"I hope he came by often / including you in his regular weeks, not just his holidays"—introduces an implicit fear: was this woman lonely? Did her son visit regularly, or only on rare occasions? This line brings a personal dimension to the impersonal sorting of possessions, reminding the reader that behind every estate sale is a life that once sought connection.

The cataloging of the deceased’s belongings continues with religious and domestic symbols: "Your angels with lace collars. Christmas cookie plate / and rattled tea towels." These objects—so intimate and seasonal—contrast with the finality of death, their presence suggesting the woman’s efforts to bring warmth and continuity to her home. However, the living "stomp between your flexible curtain road / and the dictionary with a chunk torn out," a striking contrast that portrays the estate sale as a harsh and intrusive process, where strangers move carelessly through what was once someone’s sacred space. The mention of the torn dictionary implies a rupture in language, an inability to fully articulate what is being lost.

In the kitchen, the speaker experiences a moment of reflection: "I’m caught in the kitchen with a sadness / flat as the icebox door." The phrase "caught" suggests entrapment, as if grief unexpectedly seizes the speaker amid the casual rummaging of objects. The imagery of "sadness flat as the icebox door" is evocative—cold, impersonal, and yet undeniably present, mirroring the atmosphere of detachment and sorrow.

The poem’s most poignant metaphor emerges in the final lines, where the speaker picks up "the Scrabble game with the Santa sticker / circa 1950." Unlike the other items, this game is not merely observed but "Now we’re stuck together," suggesting a reluctant but meaningful connection between the speaker and the deceased’s past. The wooden letters "click in our hands," as if attempting to spell out a message from what remains. The words they form—"ABLE, ADEPT"—suggest a lingering presence of skill and competence, yet they are ultimately disconnected. "Someone’s JIG turns into JIGSAW," reinforcing the idea of trying to fit the pieces of a life together posthumously. The final image, "Someone’s HUNCH remains just that, / though we keep flying over it from different angles, / trying to make it larger, / trying to give it feet or hands or another ground to stand on," encapsulates the struggle to reconstruct meaning from loss. The "hunch"—perhaps a metaphor for intuition or unfinished thoughts—remains unresolved, much like the life that has ended. The attempt to make it "larger" or more tangible mirrors the human desire to create narratives around death, to justify or understand it, though ultimately, some things remain elusive.

Structurally, the poem flows without stanza breaks, mimicking the movement of the estate sale itself—continuous, disorienting, with no clear divisions between grief, memory, and the transactional nature of the moment. Nye’s use of listing throughout the poem reinforces the way lives are dismantled through material possessions, each item representing a piece of an unfinished puzzle.

"Estate Sale: The Scrabble Game of a Dead Woman" is a meditation on mortality, memory, and the arbitrary nature of what gets left behind. The speaker’s presence as an observer, not just a buyer, highlights the emotional weight of sorting through a stranger’s belongings, forcing them—and the reader—to grapple with the fragments of a life now past. Through the Scrabble metaphor, Nye suggests that while we may try to rearrange and redefine loss, some things remain unsolvable, no matter how many angles we approach them from.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...