Naomi Shihab Nye’s "The Whole Self" is a meditation on identity, personal integration, and the ongoing struggle of self-formation. The poem examines the journey of becoming whole, likening it to a cycle of repeated departures and returns, assembling and reassembling, until a moment of recognition arrives. The poem’s movement, from a playful reference to the Hokey Pokey to a final image of surrender and immersion, mirrors the nonlinear process of self-discovery. Through shifting metaphors, personal reflection, and rhythmic language, Nye explores the tension between fragmentation and unity, memory and movement, hesitation and full commitment. The poem opens with a reference to the Hokey Pokey, a childhood dance song:
“You put your whole self in / You put your whole self out / Whole self in and you shake it all about.”
This seemingly simple, playful refrain immediately serves as a framework for the poem’s deeper meditation on selfhood. The game’s demand for full participation—putting the "whole self in"—becomes a metaphor for the lifelong challenge of committing to one’s identity, to existence itself. By invoking a familiar childhood chant, Nye establishes a contrast between the simplicity of the song’s instructions and the exhausting, complex reality of personal growth. The next lines introduce the speaker’s fatigue:
“When I think of the long history of the self / on its journey to becoming the whole self, I get tired.”
Here, Nye explicitly acknowledges the difficulty of self-actualization. The phrase "long history of the self" suggests an ongoing, iterative process, rather than a singular moment of realization. This exhaustion is further emphasized in the next lines:
“It was the kind of trip you keep making, / Over and over again, you pack and repack so often / the shirts start folding themselves the minute / you take them off.”
The act of packing and repacking symbolizes the constant restructuring of identity, as if the self is never fully settled. The image of "shirts start folding themselves" introduces an almost surreal, automatic repetition—an indication of how habitual and unending this process feels. The speaker then turns to memory, recalling "detailed notes in a brown notebook", marking moments when the self assembled and disassembled:
“I could tell you / when the arm joined, when it fell off again, / when the heart found the intended socket and settled down to pumping.”
These lines personify the self as a fragmented body, each part attempting to fit together. The dismembered organs reflect the instability of identity—sometimes complete, sometimes undone. The phrase "finally finally" intensifies the sense of struggle, leading to an eventual moment of recognition:
“we met up with one another / on a street corner, in October, during the noon rush.”
This moment—after repeated cycles of self-construction and collapse—suggests an epiphany, a moment when the self becomes whole in an ordinary, bustling setting. The specificity of "October" and "the noon rush" grounds the realization in lived experience, making it tangible. The transformation is further emphasized in a simple but significant shift:
“I could tell you what I was wearing. How suddenly / the face of the harried waitress made sense.”
This awareness suggests that, in finding wholeness, the world itself comes into sharper focus. The phrase "I gave my order / in a new voice" signals not just external recognition but an internal shift—language itself is different. Even the word "vegetables" carries newfound weight, described as "a precious code," highlighting the speaker’s heightened sense of connection to the everyday. However, this sense of wholeness is not without challenges. The speaker recalls a moment of regression:
“Had one relapse at a cowboy dance in Bandera, Texas, / under a sky so fat the full moon / was sitting on top of us.”
The "relapse" suggests that the process of self-formation is not linear—moments of clarity can be followed by uncertainty. The landscape itself feels overwhelming, as if the vastness of the world momentarily unmoors the speaker. This longing for something lost becomes more explicit in the next lines:
“Give me back my villages, I moaned, / the ability to touch and remove the hand / without losing anything.”
The desire for "villages"—a return to a past life, to familiarity—expresses nostalgia for a simpler or more connected time. The ability "to touch and remove the hand / without losing anything" suggests a wish for impermanence without consequence, for the ability to let go without feeling incomplete. This longing contrasts with the burden of the whole self, which requires permanence, commitment. The speaker momentarily resists full engagement:
“You put the whole self—I’ll keep with the toe.”
This half-measure reflects hesitation, a reluctance to dive in fully. But the poem resists partial commitment. The next line overturns this resistance:
“But no, it was like telling the eye not to blink.”
Just as blinking is involuntary, so too is the self’s commitment to its own wholeness. Once the process of integration begins, it cannot be undone. The final section of the poem embraces this inevitability:
“The self held on to its perimeters, committed forever, / as if the reunion could not be reversed.”
There is a permanence to the speaker’s arrival at wholeness—once recognized, the self no longer allows for fragmentation. This realization is followed by a surrender:
“I jumped inside the ring, all of me. Dance, then, and I danced, / till the room blurred like water, like blood, dance.”
The ring—perhaps another reference to the Hokey Pokey—becomes a symbol of full engagement. The repeated "dance" reflects an ecstatic, bodily embrace of selfhood. The phrase "the room blurred like water, like blood" suggests both fluidity and life force, reinforcing the idea that the self, once whole, is no longer static but alive in motion. The final lines extend this metaphor:
“The whole self was a current, a fragile cargo. / A raft someone was paddling through the jungle, / and I was there, waving, and I would be there at the other end.”
Here, the self is no longer a fragmented body or a hesitant participant; it is "a current", something moving with force and direction. Yet it remains "a fragile cargo", suggesting that wholeness, while powerful, is still delicate, still subject to change. The final image—"a raft someone was paddling through the jungle"—evokes a journey toward an unknown destination, a passage through uncertainty. The speaker is both "there, waving" and "there at the other end," implying a simultaneous presence and anticipation. The self is both in motion and fully arrived. "The Whole Self" is a profound meditation on the process of becoming, the resistance to full engagement, and the ultimate necessity of embracing one’s entirety. Through shifting metaphors—of packing and unpacking, assembling and disassembling, dancing and floating—Nye captures the complexity of self-realization. The poem suggests that while the journey to wholeness may be repetitive, exhausting, and uncertain, once arrived at, it demands full participation. In the end, the self is not something one steps in and out of—it is a current, an inevitable movement, a presence both fragile and enduring.
Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer
|
Other Poems of Interest...
|
|
