Ron Padgett’s "Advice to Young Writers" is a wry and unpretentious reflection on the creative process, offering guidance that is both practical and paradoxical. The poem begins as straightforward advice—urging writers to write even when they don’t feel like it—but gradually undermines the rigidity of this directive, expanding the definition of creativity to include everything from mowing the lawn to watching Farm News. Padgett’s signature humor and casual tone turn what might have been a prescriptive lesson into an open-ended, almost Zen-like meditation on discovery, chance, and the freedom to do nothing at all. The opening lines establish the poet as an experienced mentor:
"One of the things I've repeated to writing / students is that they should write when they don't / feel like writing, just sit down and start."
This is conventional wisdom in creative writing—discipline is essential, inspiration often follows action, and the act of writing itself generates momentum. The phrasing is informal and conversational, reinforcing the sense that the poet is speaking from experience rather than delivering an ironclad rule. The slight awkwardness of "I've repeated to writing / students"—rather than a smoother "I've often told my writing students"—adds to the poem’s offhand charm, making it feel less like a polished lecture and more like a casual admission. Padgett then extends his point:
"and when it doesn't go very well, to press on then, / to get to that one thing you'd otherwise / never find."
The suggestion here is that persistence leads to unexpected discoveries, that pushing through the struggle of uninspired writing can lead to an unforeseen moment of insight. This is the kind of advice that seems both obvious and profound—creativity often emerges from difficulty, and the reward for persistence is encountering something that would not have surfaced otherwise. The phrase "that one thing you'd otherwise / never find" is deliberately vague, allowing for the mystery and individuality of artistic breakthroughs. But then, in classic Padgett fashion, the poem turns on itself:
"What I forgot to mention was / that this is just a writing technique, that / you could also be out mowing the lawn."
The shift is subtle but significant—the absolute nature of the earlier advice is softened. Writing, it turns out, is just one way of arriving at unexpected insight. The suggestion that mowing the lawn can be just as valuable as sitting down to write expands the scope of creativity, implying that discovery is not confined to the page but is an inherent part of simply being alive and engaged in the world. The phrase "bring your mind to it" suggests that the real key to creativity is attention, not necessarily the act of writing itself. Padgett follows with two wonderfully mundane examples of such moments of unexpected discovery:
"where, / if you bring your mind to it, you'll also eventually / come to something unexpected ('The robin he / hunts and pecks'), or watching the 'Farm News' / on which a large man is referring to the 'Greater / Massachusetts area.'"
The parenthetical observation about the robin is almost a parody of poetic inspiration—one imagines the writer watching the bird, having a moment of recognition, and translating it into words. The inclusion of Farm News as a source of unexpected insight is equally charming in its ordinariness. The phrase "Greater Massachusetts area" is both meaningless and oddly profound, an example of the kind of accidental poetry that emerges from everyday language. These moments reinforce Padgett’s larger point: unexpected discoveries happen everywhere, not just when one is actively engaged in writing. The poem’s final lines drive home its ultimate message:
"It's alright, students, not / to write. Do whatever you want. As long as you find / that unexpected something, or even if you don't."
Here, the poet reverses the authoritative stance he took at the beginning. Rather than demanding discipline, he offers permission—not only to write but also not to write. The phrase "Do whatever you want" is almost comically broad, undermining the very idea of artistic obligation. And yet, the encouragement to "find that unexpected something" preserves the spirit of the original advice. The final concession—"or even if you don't"—completes the poem’s playful subversion. The pressure to create, to find meaning, is ultimately unnecessary. Writing (and life) is not about relentless productivity but about being open to what happens, whether or not it arrives. Padgett’s "Advice to Young Writers" is both an instructional poem and an anti-instructional poem. It begins with an imperative and ends with a shrug, transforming from a directive into a meditation on creative openness. The humor and humility in the poem suggest that the best advice is, ultimately, not to take advice too seriously. Whether one writes or doesn’t, whether one finds inspiration or doesn’t, the real point is simply to be present—because the unexpected, when it comes, is always enough.
Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer
|
Other Poems of Interest...
|
|
