Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Marge Piercy’s poem "Woman in a Shoe" is a poignant exploration of the plight of elderly women living in poverty and invisibility. Through a series of vignettes, Piercy vividly portrays the harsh realities faced by these women, juxtaposing their modern-day struggles with the fairy tale notion that old women possess magical powers and wisdom.

The poem begins with a reference to the familiar nursery rhyme, "There was an old woman who lived in a shoe," immediately grounding the reader in a sense of familiarity. However, Piercy subverts this image by describing the woman's actual shoes as "men’s they were, brown and worn." This detail highlights her poverty and the fact that she must make do with whatever she can find. The flapping of the shoes as she hobbles along evokes a sense of vulnerability and instability.

Piercy then presents another vignette: "There was an old woman who lived / in a refrigerator box under / the expressway with her cat. / January, they died curled together." This stark image of homelessness and death underscores the extreme marginalization and neglect experienced by some elderly women. The cold, unyielding setting of the expressway and the refrigerator box contrasts sharply with the warmth and companionship suggested by the woman and her cat curling together for warmth.

The third scenario describes a woman living "in a room under the roof. It / got hot, but she was scared / to open the window. It got hotter." This portrayal of isolation and fear illustrates the psychological toll of poverty and aging. The repetition of "too hot, too cold, too poor, / too old" emphasizes the relentless and inescapable nature of her suffering.

Piercy moves on to critique society's perception of these women: "Invisible unless / she annoys you, invisible / unless she gets in your way." This line highlights the societal disregard for the elderly unless they become a nuisance. It points to the broader issue of how society treats its most vulnerable members, often overlooking their existence until they inconvenience others.

The poem then shifts to a reflection on fairy tales, noting that in these stories, "if you are kind / to an old woman, she gives you / the thing you desperately need." This contrasts sharply with the present reality, where the idea of receiving magical rewards for kindness has become obsolete. Piercy suggests that such tales were "made up by old women scared / to be thrust from the hearth, / shoved into the street to starve," indicating that these stories were a way for elderly women to envision a world where they were valued and protected.

The poem concludes with a powerful image of an old woman "pushing / a grocery cart" and talking to God. This image evokes a sense of deep loneliness and desperation. Piercy addresses the reader directly, stating, "You / are the true child of her heart / and you see living garbage." This final line is a stark indictment of how society views and treats these women, reducing them to "living garbage" rather than recognizing their humanity and inherent worth.

"Woman in a Shoe" by Marge Piercy is a compelling and empathetic examination of the lives of elderly women living in poverty and isolation. Through vivid imagery and a critical lens, Piercy challenges the reader to confront the harsh realities faced by these women and to reconsider the societal attitudes that contribute to their invisibility and suffering. The poem serves as a powerful reminder of the need for compassion and recognition of the humanity in all individuals, regardless of their circumstances.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...