Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"In Plaster" by Sylvia Plath is a gripping exploration of duality, dependency, and identity. Through the metaphorical relationship between the narrator and her "plaster" self, the poem probes the complexities of existence, navigating the boundaries between vulnerability and strength, obedience and autonomy.

The poem begins with a startling introduction: "I shall never get out of this! There are two of me now." This immediate division of self sets the stage for an examination of human complexities and contradictions. The narrator finds herself divided into two-the old, "yellow" version and a new "absolutely white" one. The white persona is initially described as superior, a "real saint" who needs no sustenance. Yet, her sanctity feels more like a deadening, unresponsive blankness. She's compared to a dead body, "shaped just the way I was / Only much whiter and unbreakable and with no complaints."

As the poem progresses, the narrator's relationship with her other self evolves from hatred and blame to a forced sort of companionship. The narrator realizes that her other self desires love and begins to "warm up," showing her "advantages." The idea that the white self "wouldn't exist" without the narrator and is therefore "grateful" implies a relationship that is far from equal but mutually dependent. In this stage of their relationship, the white persona is presented as serving and supporting the narrator like a nurse, "holding my bones in place so they would mend properly."

However, the dynamic shifts again as the narrator starts feeling judged and slighted. The white self becomes "more and more absent-minded," and her care deteriorates. The crux of their conflict becomes evident when the narrator discerns that her other self thinks she is "immortal" and "superior," even hoping for the narrator's death. This disturbing realization illuminates the dark corners of dependency and the potential toxicity of relationships based on unequal footing. The poem thus delves into the emotional and existential ramifications of having a 'slave mentality,' as the narrator puts it.

Towards the end, the narrator foresees a future where she will "manage without her" and the white persona will "perish with emptiness then, and begin to miss me." This suggests a circularity in their dependency; each self relies on the other for existence but also perceives the other as a threat to autonomy and individuality.

"In Plaster" is a psychologically astute and emotionally charged poem. Sylvia Plath masterfully navigates the labyrinthine human psyche, laying bare the intricacies of our relationships with ourselves and others. It discusses how dependency can both heal and harm, serve and enslave. And while its focus is the complex inner terrain of human emotions and thoughts, its implications extend to broader societal discussions about power dynamics, servitude, and the constant tension between autonomy and dependency.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...