Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Mark Strand's "Elegy for My Father: 2. Answers" presents a deeply poignant dialogue that explores the dualities of human existence—truth and lies, presence and absence, connection and solitude—within the context of loss and memory. This poem, structured as a series of questions and answers, uses stark contrasts and ambiguous responses to create a layered and resonant exploration of identity, longing, and the inevitable separation brought by death.

The poem's form is deceptively simple, with alternating questions and answers, but this structure belies its emotional complexity. The repetition of certain questions—"Why did you travel?" "What did you wear?"—creates a sense of interrogation, as though the speaker seeks to reconcile disparate truths or to uncover the essence of the person being addressed. The dual responses to each question underscore the ambiguity of memory and identity, suggesting that the answers to fundamental questions about a loved one's life and motivations are often contradictory or incomplete.

In the first set of questions, "Why did you travel?" the answers shift between the pragmatic—"Because the house was cold"—and the existential—"Because it is what I have always done between sunset and sunrise." This juxtaposition captures the human tendency to search for both practical and profound explanations for our actions. The image of traveling between sunset and sunrise evokes a nocturnal, almost mythical journey, suggesting a metaphor for life's transitory nature or the passage from life to death.

The question "What did you wear?" similarly elicits two starkly different responses: one a vivid, detailed description of attire—"a blue suit, a white shirt, yellow tie, and yellow socks"—and the other a haunting abstraction—"I wore nothing. A scarf of pain kept me warm." The first answer anchors the figure of the father in the material world, while the second transcends it, emphasizing his emotional and existential suffering. The "scarf of pain" is a particularly striking image, suggesting that pain, though intangible, envelops and defines the self as thoroughly as any garment.

The duality of truth and deception emerges in the question "Why did you lie to me?" The first response, "I always thought I told the truth," implies an unintentional misalignment between perception and reality, whereas the second, "Because the truth lies like nothing else and I love the truth," highlights the paradoxical nature of truth itself. This interplay between honesty and fabrication underscores the complexities of human relationships and the ways in which memory and interpretation can distort even the most sincere intentions.

The poem crescendos with the final set of questions, which focus on departure and rest: "Why are you going?" and "How long shall I wait for you?" The answers—"Because nothing means much to me anymore" and "Do not wait for me. I am tired and I want to lie down"—convey an overwhelming sense of weariness and resignation. The repetition of the phrase "I am tired and I want to lie down" in the closing lines emphasizes the finality of the father's departure and suggests an acceptance of mortality. The tone here is both intimate and detached, as though the speaker acknowledges the inevitability of this separation while still grappling with its emotional weight.

Strand's language is precise and unadorned, allowing the emotional resonance of each line to emerge without distraction. The poem's brevity and economy of expression mirror the sparse, fragmented nature of memory and the difficulty of articulating loss. Each question and answer functions as a window into the father's life and psyche, yet the contradictions and ambiguities leave much unresolved, reflecting the speaker's struggle to reconcile conflicting images and emotions.

"Elegy for My Father: 2. Answers" is a meditation on the unknowability of others, even those closest to us, and the ways in which love, loss, and memory shape our understanding of identity. Through its interrogative structure and evocative imagery, the poem captures the tension between presence and absence, truth and falsehood, and the living and the dead. Strand's elegy is both deeply personal and universally resonant, inviting readers to reflect on their own relationships, the stories they tell themselves about those they have lost, and the unanswered questions that linger in the wake of grief.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...