Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Dara Wier’s "Not a Verbal Equivalent" is a poem of avoidance, obfuscation, and the struggle for clarity. It constructs an atmosphere of evasion and indirect meaning, where language does not straightforwardly communicate but instead functions as a shield, a puzzle, and a trap. The poem examines how words, images, and actions can be used to withhold rather than reveal, shaping a narrative that remains just out of reach.

The opening lines immediately establish a dynamic of deflection: "You said one thing as a way of not saying something else. / You wrote something so that other things wouldn't be written. / You drew me a picture of one thing and not anything else." Each statement presents an act of communication that simultaneously negates or conceals another possibility. The speaker suggests that meaning is not merely about what is expressed but also about what is left unsaid, unwritten, and undrawn. This is a poem about gaps and omissions, about how language and art serve both to disclose and to hide.

As the poem continues, the speaker wrestles with interpretation: "I'm trying to figure out how this applies to what you've gone / And done in case, by doing so, a solution to the problem we've been / Having no success solving makes itself evident." Here, meaning is elusive—something has been done, and the speaker hopes that, by deciphering its logic, an answer might emerge. However, this hope is speculative at best. The poem acknowledges the difficulty of making sense of actions and words, reinforcing its theme of ambiguity.

The narrative shifts into a hypothetical scenario: "For the sake of / Argument, let's say I'm a crime and you're a clue and someone / Else, we don't know who, is the detective." This metaphor transforms the act of interpretation into an investigation. The speaker and the addressee are not merely participants in an unclear situation; they are reconfigured into elements of a mystery—one as the crime itself, the other as the clue to its resolution. Yet the detective, the figure who should bring clarity, remains unidentified. The mystery remains unsolved, underscoring the poem’s central tension between communication and concealment.

The setting then emerges: "We're on the Wind River and it's twilight and you have on your windbreaker of many / Pockets and I have on my boots in which I hide whatever needs / To be hidden." This landscape is atmospheric and cinematic, reinforcing the sense of secrecy. The Wind River—a real location but also a suggestive name—implies movement, transience, and the difficulty of grasping meaning. Twilight, a liminal time, further adds to the poem’s sense of uncertainty. The windbreaker with "many pockets" suggests storage and concealment, while the speaker’s boots become a site for hiding things—although, in a moment of contradiction, they add: "To be perfectly accurate you are barefoot and I / Have nothing to hide at the moment." Just as the reader thinks they are getting a clearer image, the poem destabilizes itself, reinforcing its own theme of slippery meaning.

The final images—"Wild geese. Two butterflies / Of black and blue geometry. A coal train. Skid marks on the / Curve in the road that will point us slowly into a nearby cave."—are precise yet enigmatic. Wild geese symbolize migration and fleeting movement. The butterflies, with their "black and blue geometry," evoke both fragility and a structured pattern. The coal train introduces industrial weight, a sense of labor and inexorable motion. Finally, "Skid marks on the / Curve in the road" suggest an accident, a loss of control—leading not to resolution but to a "nearby cave." The cave, a traditional symbol of mystery, darkness, and hidden knowledge, becomes the final destination, further emphasizing the poem’s refusal to offer a straightforward conclusion.

Wier’s "Not a Verbal Equivalent" is a poem about the limits of language and the complexities of understanding. It dramatizes the ways we speak, write, and create in order to avoid certain truths while seeking others. The use of crime and investigation as a framework suggests that meaning is something to be pursued, yet the imagery—wild geese, butterflies, skid marks—reminds us that not everything can be neatly solved. The cave at the poem’s end is perhaps the ultimate metaphor: a place of concealment and potential discovery, where language both reveals and withholds, always leading us further into ambiguity.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...