Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Richard Wilbur’s "Another Voice" is a deeply reflective poem that grapples with the paradoxes of violence, grief, and the human need to reckon with suffering. Through compact, carefully wrought stanzas, Wilbur examines the tension between the unspeakable truths of the soul and the human compulsion to seek meaning in pain. The poem’s title suggests a voice that stands apart—an alternative perspective that offers both wisdom and restraint in the face of chaos and sorrow.

The opening stanza introduces the central paradox: “The sword bites for peace, / Yet how should that be said.” This phrase encapsulates the contradiction of seeking peace through violence, a theme that resonates across historical and contemporary conflicts. The "sword" becomes a symbol of both destruction and the flawed hope for resolution, while the rhetorical question underscores the difficulty of articulating such a paradox. The phrase “howling Greece” situates the poem in a historical and mythic context, evoking the Peloponnesian War and the internecine strife of Corcyra (modern Corfu), a key episode in Thucydides? History of the Peloponnesian War. This reference to ancient civil war serves as a timeless metaphor for human discord and suffering.

The line “Corcyra! cry the crows, / And blacken all our sky” introduces a striking visual and auditory image. The crows, traditional symbols of death and misfortune, transform the natural world into a manifestation of collective grief and despair. The blackened sky mirrors the weight of sorrow and the pervasive darkness that follows violence. The speaker observes that “The soul knows what it knows, / But may not make reply,” suggesting an ineffable truth beyond the reach of language. This acknowledgment of the soul’s silent wisdom highlights the limitations of expression in the face of profound pain, reinforcing the poem’s central tension between knowledge and articulation.

The second stanza shifts to a more intimate tone, reflecting on the personal dimensions of anguish: “From a good face gone mad, / From false or hissing tongue, / What comfort’s to be had, / What sweetness can be wrung?” These lines portray a world fractured by betrayal and madness, where familiar sources of solace—faces and voices—become sources of distress. The imagery evokes a sense of disillusionment, where even the most trusted or cherished aspects of life are tainted by suffering. The speaker’s rhetorical questions emphasize the futility of seeking comfort or sweetness in such circumstances, underscoring the raw reality of pain.

The stanza concludes with a stark observation: “It is the human thing / To reckon pain as pain.” This line distills the essence of the human condition, affirming the inevitability of suffering and the necessity of acknowledging it without adornment or justification. Wilbur’s use of the phrase “the human thing” lends the statement a universality, grounding the poem in shared experience. The simplicity of this declaration contrasts with the earlier complexity of the paradoxes, offering a moment of clarity and acceptance.

The final lines provide a quiet resolution: “If soul in quiet sing, / Better not to explain.” This concluding couplet suggests a retreat from the compulsion to rationalize or verbalize suffering. The image of the soul singing in quiet emphasizes a form of solace that is internal, instinctual, and beyond explanation. The speaker implies that some truths—particularly those of the soul—are better left unspoken, allowing their resonance to exist without the constraints of language. This restraint reflects the poem’s broader ethos: an acknowledgment of the limits of reason and expression in addressing the profound and the ineffable.

Structurally, "Another Voice" employs quatrains with alternating rhyme, creating a measured, contemplative rhythm that mirrors the poem’s tone. The brevity and precision of the lines underscore the weight of the ideas, allowing each image and statement to resonate deeply. Wilbur’s language is both lyrical and unadorned, balancing the intellectual complexity of the themes with the emotional immediacy of the imagery.

"Another Voice" is a meditation on the intersection of suffering, silence, and the limits of human understanding. By invoking historical conflict, personal anguish, and the ineffable truths of the soul, Wilbur crafts a poem that speaks to the universal experience of pain and the difficulty of making sense of it. The poem’s restrained tone and reflective insights invite readers to consider the value of quiet acceptance and the wisdom of leaving some truths unspoken. Through its poignant exploration of these themes, "Another Voice" becomes a timeless reflection on the human condition.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...