Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Richard Wilbur’s "Seed Leaves; Homage to R. F." is a contemplative and layered poem that pays tribute to Robert Frost while meditating on themes of growth, potential, and the tension between aspiration and limitation. The poem uses the metaphor of a sprouting seedling to explore existential questions about identity, ambition, and the relationship between the individual and the broader universe. Through its careful imagery and deliberate progression, the poem evokes both Frost’s sensibility and Wilbur’s own philosophical depth.

The poem opens with the image of a seedling emerging from the ground: “Here something stubborn comes, / Dislodging the earth crumbs.” The description of the seedling as “stubborn” captures its determination to break through the crust of the earth, an act emblematic of persistence and vitality. The depiction of the seedling as “bending double” and resembling “a green staple” emphasizes its initial awkwardness and lack of definition. At this stage, its identity remains uncertain—“It could be seedling maple, / Or artichoke, or bean.” This ambiguity highlights the seedling’s potential, a state of becoming that is open to multiple possibilities.

As the seedling progresses, it faces the inevitability of growth and self-definition: “Forced to make choice of ends, / The stalk in time unbends.” The act of unbending, of shedding its seed-case and revealing its first leaves, symbolizes a transition from formless potential to individuality. The “two leaves” that emerge are described as “toothless and fat,” retaining the “oval form of sleep.” This image suggests that, while the seedling has begun to grow, it still clings to a state of embryonic simplicity, reluctant to fully commit to its eventual form.

The central tension of the poem lies in the seedling’s desire to grow while avoiding the constraints of definition: “This plant would like to grow / And yet be embryo.” The juxtaposition of growth and stasis encapsulates the paradox of ambition—an urge to expand and achieve without losing the boundless potential of the undefined. Wilbur likens this yearning to “boundless Igdrasil / That has the stars for fruit.” The reference to Yggdrasil, the cosmic tree of Norse mythology, elevates the seedling’s aspirations to a universal scale, suggesting a desire to transcend the limitations of individual existence and merge with the infinite.

However, the poem introduces a counterforce: “But something at the root / More urgent than the urge / Bids two true leaves emerge.” This force represents the inescapable reality of growth and self-definition, a process that requires the seedling to take on a specific form and identity. The phrase “resigned to being self-defined” underscores the tension between the seedling’s expansive aspirations and the necessity of grounding itself in the physical world. The act of producing “true leaves” signifies the transition from potential to actuality, from an undefined embryo to a distinct and purposeful entity.

The closing lines of the poem celebrate the seedling’s resolve to embrace its individuality while striving toward the sky: “Takes aim at all the sky / And starts to ramify.” The word “ramify,” meaning to branch out or develop in complexity, encapsulates the dual nature of the seedling’s journey—it must grow and spread, becoming both more defined and more intricate. This process of self-definition does not diminish its ambition; rather, it channels its boundless energy into a specific, meaningful trajectory.

Wilbur’s homage to Robert Frost is evident in the poem’s attention to nature, its philosophical underpinnings, and its exploration of universal truths through specific, grounded imagery. Like Frost, Wilbur uses the natural world as a metaphor for human experience, delving into questions of purpose, identity, and the tension between individual ambition and universal forces. The seedling’s journey mirrors the human condition, capturing the struggle to balance the desire for freedom and boundlessness with the necessity of growth, change, and definition.

The poem’s formal structure, with its consistent rhyming couplets, reflects a sense of order and progression, mirroring the seedling’s gradual emergence and development. The language is precise and evocative, blending the physicality of the seedling’s growth with the abstract themes of potential and limitation.

"Seed Leaves; Homage to R. F." is ultimately a meditation on the nature of growth and the inevitable process of becoming. Through its rich imagery and philosophical depth, the poem celebrates the seedling’s—and by extension, humanity’s—capacity to strive, adapt, and expand, even within the constraints of individuality and form. By honoring Frost’s legacy, Wilbur situates his reflection within a broader poetic tradition, inviting readers to consider their own place in the dynamic interplay between potential and purpose.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...