Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"The Comfort of a Woman" by Ralph Burns is a poignant narrative poem that explores themes of friendship, love, and the complexities of human relationships. Through a vivid recounting of a fishing trip intertwined with a dream and reflections on marital companionship, Burns delves into the nuances of emotional intimacy and the comfort that comes from understanding and being understood by another person.

The poem begins with the speaker waking up to the unsettling smell of furnace gas, an immediate signal of danger or discomfort that transitions into a recounting of a dream. In this dream, the speaker learns that his friend has proposed to Charlotte, a revelation that comes after a day of fishing at Lake Conway. The detailed description of the bait-man, the crickets, and the setting by the cyprus stump grounds the narrative in a sense of reality, blurring the lines between dream and waking life.

The friend's declaration of love for Charlotte in the dream is straightforward, yet it contrasts with the speaker's later correction of Charlotte's physical attributes in reality. This discrepancy between the dream and reality suggests the speaker's struggle to reconcile his friend's choice with his own perceptions, highlighting the subjectivity of attraction and the mysteries of love.

As the poem unfolds, the fishing trip serves as a backdrop for exploring deeper themes. The mention of mallards and the explanation of why female ducks are drab for camouflage purposes introduces a layer of commentary on gender roles and the instinct for protection. This naturalistic observation parallels the poem's broader contemplation of human relationships, suggesting that appearances and behaviors are often adapted for survival and fulfillment.

The return to bed, where the speaker finds his own wife warm beside him, brings the narrative back to the personal and immediate. The comfort of his wife's presence offers a stark contrast to the earlier discomfort of the furnace gas smell and the unsettling dream. It is in this moment of closeness and warmth that the speaker reflects on the concept of "good fortune" in love, envisioning for his friend a partner who is idealized and perhaps unrealistic, "blonde as a sunfish, small-boned as a sparrow."

"The Comfort of a Woman" captures the complexity of wishing well for a friend while grappling with one's own ideals and realities of love and partnership. Burns's narrative skillfully weaves together the tangible and the symbolic, the personal and the universal, offering a meditation on the ways in which love, friendship, and the natural world intersect and inform our understanding of ourselves and each other. Through its evocative imagery and thoughtful reflections, the poem invites readers to consider the sources of comfort and companionship in their own lives, and the delicate balance between accepting others' choices and nurturing our own visions of happiness.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...