Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"The Death of Allegory" by Billy Collins is a contemplative piece that mourns the fading relevance of allegorical figures and the abstract ideals they represent in the modern world. Through the lens of allegory, Collins explores the shift in cultural and aesthetic values over time, juxtaposing the grandeur and significance of allegorical entities during the Renaissance with their perceived obsolescence in contemporary society. The poem navigates through the realms of art, literature, and collective consciousness, presenting a narrative of transition from the metaphorical to the literal, from the emblematic to the tangible.

Collins begins by reminiscing about the allegorical figures that once dominated the artistic and literary landscapes, personifying abstract concepts such as Truth, Chastity, Courtesy, Villainy, Reason, and Constancy. These figures, characterized by their capital letters and emblematic appearances, were once central to the portrayal of moral and philosophical themes, embodying ideas larger than life itself. They were depicted as statuesque and dynamic, engaging with the viewer or reader in a manner that bridged the divine and the earthly, the ideal and the real.

However, the poem then shifts to a whimsical yet poignant envisioning of these allegorical figures in retirement, suggesting that they have been relegated to a metaphorical Florida for tropes—a place where outdated or overused literary devices are imagined to spend their twilight years. Collins humorously depicts figures like Justice standing idly by an open refrigerator and Valor lying in bed listening to the rain, suggesting that these once-venerated ideals have been stripped of their roles and significance in the modern consciousness.

The abandonment of allegory is further emphasized through the modern world's lack of suitable places for these figures. The Garden of Mirth, the Bower of Bliss, and the Valley of Forgiveness—once fertile grounds for allegorical exploration—are now obscured by the encroachments of contemporary life, such as condominiums and the disturbing noise of chainsaws in the Forest of Despair. This transition signifies a cultural shift towards pragmatism and materialism, away from the contemplative appreciation of abstract virtues and vices.

Collins contrasts the grand allegorical narratives with the simple, unadorned objects of modern preference: a vase of peonies, black binoculars, and a money clip. These items, devoid of any grand symbolic meaning, represent a move towards valuing the literal and the immediate. They exist "in lower case," a poetic device Collins uses to emphasize their simplicity and ordinariness compared to the capitalized Allegories of the past.

The poem concludes with a melancholic reflection on the fate of the allegorical figures, suggesting they have vanished into the unseen valley of a storybook ending—a place beyond the reach of the contemporary world, where they presumably rest in oblivion. This image serves as a metaphor for the cultural and philosophical distance we have traveled from an era when allegory served as a primary means of exploring and conveying the complexities of human experience and the abstract ideals that guide it.

Through "The Death of Allegory," Billy Collins engages in a reflective examination of how the modes of understanding and expressing the human condition have evolved. The poem laments the loss of a symbolic language that once enriched the collective imagination, inviting readers to contemplate the implications of this shift for how we conceive of and communicate about the world and our place within it. In its elegiac tone and imaginative portrayal of allegory's decline, the poem offers a poignant commentary on the changing landscape of human thought and culture.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...