Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"The Province" by Robert Creeley presents a sharp and critical reflection on the disconnection between political or military actions and their broader implications on humanity and the world. Through its conversational tone and strategic use of colloquial language, the poem critiques the abstraction and depersonalization often found in discussions about geopolitical conflicts and military strategies. Creeley's work here is marked by its directness and its challenge to conventional perceptions of power and control, particularly in the context of war and international relations.

The opening lines, "Trying to get 'our men back' and 'our ship back' —'tactical nuclear weapons' —dig! Shee-it," immediately immerse the reader in the midst of a critical commentary on the rhetoric used by governments or military entities in their pursuit of objectives. The phrases "our men back" and "our ship back" evoke a sense of possession and entitlement, suggesting a reduction of human lives and complex situations to mere assets or pawns in a strategic game. The mention of "tactical nuclear weapons" amplifies this critique, highlighting the stark and disturbing contrast between the casual tone and the devastating realities such weapons represent. The interjection "dig! Shee-it" serves to mock the seriousness with which such matters are often discussed, suggesting a deep skepticism of the motives and the language used in these contexts.

Creeley then shifts focus to address a broader audience or perhaps a specific figure ("dad"), suggesting a generational dialogue or critique. The phrase "The world, dad, is where you live unless you've forgotten it" is a poignant reminder of the tangible, lived realities that are at stake in geopolitical maneuvers. This line challenges the detachment and abstraction that can come from viewing the world through the lens of "efficacy or understanding or superior lines of or, or something else." Creeley suggests that such perspectives, while perhaps intended to rationalize or justify actions, ultimately serve to disconnect individuals from the ethical and human implications of their decisions.

The poem's critique of "efficacy" and the pursuit of "understanding" or "superior lines" underscores a tension between the pursuit of strategic advantages and the fundamental human connection to the world and to each other. Creeley uses the phrase "or something else" to hint at the myriad ways in which language and rationalization can obscure the simple truths of existence and cohabitation on this planet.

"The Province" is a compelling critique of the ways in which geopolitical and military rhetoric can dehumanize and distance individuals from the realities of their actions. Through its succinct yet powerful language, Creeley calls for a reevaluation of the priorities and perspectives that guide such discussions, advocating for a more grounded and human-centric approach to understanding our place in the world. The poem serves as a reminder that behind the strategic objectives and political rhetoric lie real human lives and a shared world that requires our care and respect.

POEM TEXT: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poetrymagazine/browse?contentId=30994

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...