Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"If You" by Robert Creeley is a contemplative and slightly whimsical poem that explores the theme of desire and the transient nature of life through the lens of contemplating a pet. The poem oscillates between the tangible and the philosophical, grounding its exploration of existence and mortality in the simple question of what kind of pet one might choose.

The poem begins with a seemingly innocent inquiry: "If you were going to get a pet what kind of animal would you get." This question, while straightforward, opens a space for deeper reflection on the qualities we seek in companionship, be it from a pet or metaphorically in our human relationships. The mention of "A soft bodied dog, a hen— / feathers and fur to begin it again" introduces the idea of comfort and renewal that animals can bring into our lives, emphasizing the tactile and nurturing aspects of this bond.

The shift to "When the sun goes down and it gets dark / I saw an animal in a park. / Bring it home, to give it to you." adds an element of mystery and spontaneity, suggesting that sometimes the companions we find or choose come unexpectedly into our lives. This act of bringing the animal home as a gift underscores the poem's focus on the giving and receiving of care, and the joy found in unexpected connections.

However, the poem takes a darker turn with "I have seen animals break in two." This line introduces the theme of fragility and the inevitability of loss, reminding the reader that all living beings are subject to harm and mortality. This acknowledgment of vulnerability contrasts sharply with the earlier hope for "something soft and loyal and clean and wondrously careful," highlighting the tension between our desires for ideal companionship and the harsh realities of life.

Creeley then introduces the image of a rabbit, "a form of otherwise vicious habit can have long ears and be called a rabbit," playing on the dual nature of animals (and by extension, people) who can possess both gentle and harsh qualities. The abrupt mention of "Dead. Died. Will die. Want." starkly reminds the reader of the cycle of life and death, underscoring the inevitability of loss that accompanies love and attachment.

The poem concludes by circling back to the initial question, now laden with the added weight of the poem's exploration of desire, mortality, and the complexity of care. This return to the beginning serves to emphasize the ongoing nature of these reflections, inviting the reader to consider their own desires and the transient nature of all relationships.

"If You" weaves together the simplicity of contemplating a pet with profound reflections on the human condition, capturing the beauty and pain of attachment, the complexity of desire, and the inevitable presence of mortality in all aspects of life. Through its lyrical exploration, Creeley invites the reader to ponder the depths of their own desires and the fragile, precious nature of companionship, be it with animals or humans.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...