Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Robert Creeley’s "In Secret" is a compact and enigmatic poem that explores themes of paradox, cycles, and the tension between knowledge and ignorance. Creeley’s use of simple yet paradoxical language invites the reader to contemplate the nature of wisdom, the illusion of understanding, and the inevitability of repetition. The poem employs minimalistic language and circular imagery, emphasizing a sense of movement and continuity, while also presenting a subtle critique of human attempts to grasp the complexities of existence.

The poem opens with the phrase "IN SECRET the out's in—" which establishes an immediate paradox. The capitalization of "IN SECRET" emphasizes the concealed or enigmatic nature of what is being described. By stating that “the out’s in,” Creeley suggests a blurring of boundaries or a reversal of expectations. This phrase can be interpreted as an indication of hidden truths or an inversion of what is perceived to be outside and inside, signaling the fluidity and ambiguity of the speaker’s subject matter. The notion of secrecy implies that there is a hidden or deeper understanding that remains elusive or obscured.

The next line, "the wise surprised, all / going coming, begun undone," continues the theme of paradox and circularity. The phrase “the wise surprised” suggests that even those who consider themselves knowledgeable or perceptive are caught off guard by the hidden nature of reality. The juxtaposition of “wise” and “surprised” hints at the limitations of wisdom and the inevitability of encountering the unexpected. The following line, “all going coming, begun undone,” emphasizes the cyclical and fluid nature of events. This use of opposing verbs—“going” and “coming,” “begun” and “undone”—conveys a sense of movement that is both continuous and contradictory. The repetition of actions in opposing directions suggests an eternal process of creation and destruction, beginning and ending, without a clear resolution.

The line "Hence the fool dances in endless happiness." presents a contrast between the wise and the fool. The fool, often a figure of simplicity or ignorance, finds joy in this cyclical existence, seemingly unburdened by the complexity that surprises the wise. The word “hence” implies causation, as if the fool’s happiness is a result of this paradoxical reality. The fool’s dance suggests a state of acceptance or even celebration of life’s contradictions, reflecting a carefree or liberated attitude towards the complexities of existence. This line implies that there is a certain wisdom in embracing the unknown and finding happiness in the midst of paradox and uncertainty.

The visual break in the poem, marked by a dot (•), serves as a pause, inviting the reader to reflect on the preceding lines before transitioning to the next image. This pause creates a moment of contemplation, emphasizing the reflective nature of the poem.

In the second part of the poem, Creeley introduces a striking image: "A circling with snake-tail in mouth—" This imagery evokes the ancient symbol of the ouroboros, a snake eating its own tail, which traditionally represents cycles, eternity, and the unity of opposites. The image of the snake suggests an eternal, self-sustaining loop, reinforcing the themes of circularity and paradox introduced earlier in the poem. The ouroboros can also symbolize the interconnectedness of beginnings and endings, reinforcing the idea that creation and destruction are inherently linked.

Creeley then describes the snake’s head as looking forward while what is backward is left to be guessed: "what the head was looked forward, what backward is, then guess." This line emphasizes the limits of perception and knowledge. The snake’s forward-looking head implies a focus on what lies ahead, but the backward orientation remains ambiguous, leaving the reader to speculate about what is unseen or unknown. The use of the word “guess” suggests that understanding the past or the hidden aspects of reality is ultimately a matter of conjecture or interpretation, rather than certainty. This line reflects the theme of human limitation in comprehending the full scope of existence, and the futility of trying to understand everything with absolute clarity.

The final line, "Either way, it will stay," concludes the poem with a sense of permanence and inevitability. Regardless of whether one looks forward or backward, or whether one is wise or a fool, the cyclical nature of reality remains unchanged. This line suggests an acceptance of the unchanging nature of the world’s contradictions and the futility of trying to alter or escape them. The phrase “it will stay” implies a sense of constancy, reinforcing the idea that life’s paradoxes and cycles are fundamental and enduring.

Throughout "In Secret," Creeley employs paradoxical language and circular imagery to explore the tension between knowledge and ignorance, and the inevitability of life’s contradictions. The poem suggests that wisdom does not necessarily bring clarity or resolution, and that happiness may lie in embracing the fluidity and uncertainty of existence. The contrast between the wise and the fool, and the imagery of the ouroboros, highlight the themes of repetition and the limits of human understanding.

Creeley’s minimalist style and carefully chosen language invite readers to engage with the poem’s ambiguities and reflect on their own perceptions of reality. By presenting a world where the boundaries between inside and outside, beginning and ending, and wisdom and folly are fluid and intertwined, "In Secret" encourages readers to question their assumptions and embrace the mystery and continuity of existence. Ultimately, the poem suggests that true wisdom may lie not in resolving these paradoxes, but in accepting and finding joy within them.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...