Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Can Poetry Matter?" by Stephen Dobyns is a satirical and reflective piece that delves into the complexities and absurdities of creating poetry in the modern world. Through the character of Heart, a poet wrestling with the significance and substance of his work, Dobyns explores the tension between the desire for poetic expression and the challenge of finding meaning and authenticity in art. The poem humorously interrogates the relationship between the poet, the critic, and the audience, ultimately questioning the nature and purpose of poetry itself.

Heart's initial endeavor to write lyric poetry is fraught with indecision and doubt as he grapples with the symbolism of the moon—whether it embodies joy or sorrow, is a beacon of pleasure or a symbol of distress. This uncertainty about how to interpret and articulate his experience speaks to the poet's struggle with the elusiveness of meaning in poetry. The overcast night sky, obscuring the moon, becomes a metaphor for the obscurity and inaccessibility of clear, unequivocal inspiration or insight.

The array of interpretations offered by scientists, astrologers, a neighbor, and a conspiracy theorist highlights the subjective nature of meaning, especially in the context of poetic symbolism. Each perspective on the moon—from a dead rock to a symbol of love or Satanic influence—reflects the diverse and often contradictory ways in which people seek to understand and ascribe significance to the world around them.

Heart's solution to his dilemma—embracing nonsensical and absurd imagery—represents a rejection of conventional expectations and an assertion of artistic freedom. However, this freedom comes at the cost of coherence and connection with the audience. The critic's interpretation of Heart's poem as a reflection of a childhood trauma related to water humorously underscores the often speculative and far-fetched analyses that can distance poetry from its intended meaning or essence.

Dobyns's depiction of Heart and the critic as partners in a "sausage factory of poetry" serves as a critique of the commercialization and mechanization of art, where originality and substance can be sacrificed for productivity and marketability. The imagery of "pig snouts and ***** tissue of language" enclosed in "a thin membrane of explication" suggests a process of artistic creation that has become disconnected from genuine expression and understanding, reduced instead to a commodity.

Ultimately, "Can Poetry Matter?" poses a profound inquiry into the value and impact of poetry in contemporary society. Through its satirical tone and inventive imagery, the poem challenges readers to consider what constitutes meaningful poetry and to reflect on the roles of the poet, the critic, and the reader in the creation and interpretation of art. Dobyns's work is a playful yet poignant meditation on the possibilities and limitations of poetic expression, inviting a deeper contemplation of how poetry can matter in an age of uncertainty and multiplicity of meanings.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...