Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Natasha Trethewey's "Incident," the veneer of tranquility is shattered by the haunting recollection of a traumatic event. Despite its title, the poem contends that "nothing really happened," a line that reverberates with irony as the poem unfolds. Written in the form of a pantoum, a Malay form that relies on repeated lines, the poem creates a cyclical structure that mimics the way traumatic memories and racial violence persist across time.

The poem begins with the line "We tell the story every year," instantly pulling the reader into a ritual of remembrance. Immediately, this raises questions about what story is so significant that it demands an annual retelling. As we learn, the story is a chilling account of a cross burning, an act laden with the historical and contemporary baggage of racial terror. What's most disturbing is the domestic frame of this violence. The shades are drawn; people peer from windows, a cross is "trussed like a Christmas tree," a grotesque inversion of a symbol usually associated with family and joy.

Trethewey infuses the poem with unsettling contrasts. The men are "white as angels in their gowns," the word "angels" subverted by the men's participation in an act of racial terror. This calls attention to the ways language and symbols often work to normalize or sanitize the realities of hate. The flames of the burning cross are paralleled by the "flames" in the "hurricane lamps," as if the fire outside threatens to ignite the interior domestic space.

The recurring line "Nothing really happened" is particularly devastating. On one level, it reflects a horrifying normalcy: the event was traumatic, yet life carries on-the grass grows green again, people continue with their lives. Yet it also speaks to the erasure or minimization of racial trauma that is often overlooked or normalized in broader societal narratives.

The line "We tell the story every year" closes the poem, emphasizing the cyclical nature of racial violence and the need for storytelling as both an act of collective memory and resistance. The ritual of telling becomes a counterpoint to the normalization of racial violence; it's a way to insist that something did happen, something that should not be minimized or forgotten.

The pantoum form itself becomes a powerful metaphor for how history repeats itself, how past events continue to resonate in the present. Each repeated line is like a haunting echo, a reminder that the incident described is not isolated but part of a longer, ongoing history of racialized violence.

"Incident" is a poignant exploration of how racial trauma infiltrates the domestic sphere, revealing that the home is not always a sanctuary and that the ghosts of history can never be easily shut out, no matter how tightly we draw the shades.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...