Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Elegy for My Father" by Natasha Trethewey is a poignant poem that delves into the intricate relationship between a father and daughter, framed within the activity of fishing. The river, filled with salmon in late August, serves as a metaphorical space where memories, losses, and lessons are reeled in and released. The poem's setting, amidst the drizzle and mist, creates an atmospheric backdrop for exploring these emotions.

The drizzle and mist are not merely physical elements; they are laden with symbolic resonance. They serve as a veil, both illuminating and obscuring the scene, much like memories themselves. The mist is "like a net settling around us," indicating that while some things are caught in the mesh of memory, others are destined to slip through. The water-logged boots that render the father "heavy with that defeat" evoke not just the immediacy of the fishing expedition, but also life's many burdens-lost opportunities, regrets, things left unsaid-that add weight to our emotional landscape.

Throughout the poem, the act of fishing becomes a nuanced symbol. The daughter observes her father miming their guide's casting and later trying to find "that perfect arc, flight of an insect skimming the river's surface." It's a struggle to attain perfection in action and maybe, by extension, in relationships. She herself reels in "two small trout we could not keep," leading her to reflect upon the nature of attachment and letting go. She thinks about "the past-working the hooks loose, the fish writhing in my hands, each one slipping away before I could let go." These fish symbolize not only missed opportunities but also the ephemeral nature of life and relationships, which can't always be held onto despite our best efforts.

This elegy, while recounting a specific experience, is also the daughter's attempt to record the impermanent, knowing that her father won't be there forever. Her admission, "Your daughter, I was that ruthless. What does it matter if I tell you I learned to be?" is heartrending in its honesty. She acknowledges her calculated emotional distance, not as a natural disposition, but as a learned mechanism to navigate the complicated currents of their relationship.

Interestingly, the daughter acknowledges her intent to one day write this very elegy. It's a moment of startling self-awareness. This metatextual aspect of the poem adds another layer, giving the poem the gravity of a long-considered tribute as well as a spontaneous outpouring of grief.

The poem closes with the image of the small boat moving away from the bank, her back "to where I know we are headed." It's a potent image that encapsulates the essence of the elegy-the inescapable forward motion of life and death.

"Elegy for My Father" captures the complex emotional topology of parental relationships. It underscores how experiences and memories can serve as both buoys and anchors in the river of life, which is itself in constant, indifferent motion. Through evocative imagery and skillful symbolism, Trethewey offers a map of love, loss, and acceptance, allowing readers to navigate their own rivers filled with personal salmons of regret and trout of fleeting joy.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...