Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Love Song: I and Thou" by Alan Dugan is a raw and powerful poem that uses the metaphor of a poorly constructed house to explore themes of personal struggle, imperfection, and the human need for companionship and support. The poem's tone is gritty and intense, reflecting the speaker's frustration with both his life and the literal structure he has built, which ultimately serves as a poignant symbol for his emotional and existential state.

The poem begins with an admission of imperfection: "Nothing is plumb, level, or square." This line sets the stage for a confession about the flawed nature of the speaker's endeavors—both in carpentry and, implicitly, in life. The description of the construction process is filled with defects: bowed studs, shaky joists, gaps, pinches, and "bent nails dance all over the surfacing like maggots." The chaotic imagery evokes a sense of decay and disrepair, suggesting that the speaker's life, like his construction, is fundamentally unstable and riddled with problems.

Dugan uses the image of the self-built house to delve deeply into the speaker's psyche, revealing his isolation and anger. He confesses, "By Christ I am no carpenter. I built the roof for myself, the walls for myself, the floors for myself, and got hung up in it myself." The repetition of "for myself" underscores a profound solitude and self-reliance, which is not celebrated but presented as a trap—the speaker is literally "hung up" in the solitary life he has constructed.

The house-warming scene is depicted with intense emotion: "I danced with a purple thumb at this house-warming, drunk with my prime whiskey: rage." Here, rage is both the cause and the companion of his labor, driving the construction and the celebration. The speaker acknowledges that his anger fuels his endeavors, even as it poisons them, suggesting a complex relationship with his own emotions and actions.

Despite the foundational flaws, there is a fleeting moment of triumph: "Oh I spat rage’s nails into the frame-up of my work: it held. It settled plumb, level, solid, square and true for that great moment." However, this victory is short-lived, as the structure soon "screamed and went on through, skewing as wrong the other way." This dramatic shift—from stability back to chaos—mirrors the tumultuous nature of the speaker's internal world, highlighting the temporary and fragile nature of any semblance of order or success in his life.

The poem concludes with a poignant recognition of the speaker's limitations and his need for others: "I can nail my left palm to the left-hand crosspiece but I can’t do everything myself. I need a hand to nail the right, a help, a love, a you, a wife." This final stanza shifts from the solitary "I" to the relational "Thou," underscoring the human need for connection and assistance. The crucifixion imagery suggests a sacrifice and suffering that cannot be borne alone, emphasizing the necessity of partnership in facing the burdens of life.

Overall, "Love Song: I and Thou" is a deeply metaphorical and emotionally charged poem that reflects on the flawed nature of human efforts and the essential need for love and companionship. Through the extended metaphor of building and dwelling in a flawed house, Alan Dugan masterfully explores themes of isolation, frustration, and the redemptive power of human relationships.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...