Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Emily Dickinson's "This World is not Conclusion" is a dense, thought-provoking poem that delves into metaphysical queries, particularly the eternal tension between belief and doubt, the knowable and the unknowable. It grapples with the ineffable aspect of what lies beyond the physical world, touching upon themes of faith, philosophy, and the eternal quest for understanding. The poem comprises five quatrains, and like much of Dickinson's work, it employs dashes and unconventional punctuation to unsettle conventional interpretation and rhythmic flow.

The poem opens with a bold assertion: "This World is not Conclusion." This single line serves as a sweeping repudiation of materialism, positivism, and any philosophical system that confines reality to tangible experience. The next lines describe the ineffable "Species" that "stands beyond"-a realm or state of being that is "Invisible, as Music - / But positive, as Sound -". Dickinson invokes music and sound as metaphors for this ineffable truth: invisible yet indisputably real. It is a poignant choice, encapsulating the duality of what is felt but not seen.

The poem continues to emphasize the enigmatic quality of this elusive "Species," stating that it "beckons, and it baffles -". This "baffling" nature of the eternal is such that "Philosophy, dont know - / And through a Riddle, at the last - / Sagacity, must go -". Human reason and wisdom, encapsulated in the terms "Philosophy" and "Sagacity," are inadequate tools for comprehending what lies beyond the material world. Even the most enlightened scholars can only "guess" at its nature.

The lines "To gain it, Men have borne / Contempt of Generations / And Crucifixion, shown -" allude to the extreme measures, including social ostracization and martyrdom, that individuals have undergone to obtain this elusive knowledge or state. This could be a veiled reference to religious figures or philosophers who faced persecution for their nonconformist beliefs.

Faith, the cornerstone of spiritual belief, is portrayed as a dynamic, vulnerable entity: "Faith slips - and laughs, and rallies - / Blushes, if any see - / Plucks at a twig of Evidence - / And asks a Vane, the way -". Here, faith is not a monolithic, unchanging virtue but a fluctuating state of being. It seeks evidence, asking for directions like a weather vane, susceptible to doubt yet resilient enough to rally and blush.

Dickinson concludes with a critique of organized religion, perhaps a reflection of her own complicated relationship with the Calvinistic faith of her upbringing. "Much Gesture, from the Pulpit - / Strong Hallelujahs roll -" suggests that religious rituals and exclamations are insufficient. Even narcotics, symbolic of any physical or material palliative, "cannot still the Tooth / That nibbles at the soul -". This soul-deep craving for understanding and truth remains unsatisfied by the superficial comforts offered by organized religion or materialistic philosophy.

Situated in a 19th-century American context, where Transcendentalism and religious revivalism often clashed with scientific rationalism, Dickinson's poem serves as a nuanced testament to the complexities of faith and doubt in an era grappling with rapid intellectual and spiritual changes.

In summary, "This World is not Conclusion" acts as an eloquent critique of both empirical skepticism and blind faith. Through its intricate structure and nuanced lexicon, the poem challenges the reader to confront the limitations of human knowledge and the complexities of faith, in a world that both "beckons and baffles."

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...