Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Emily Dickinson's poem "With Flowers" delves into the complexities of memory, forgetting, and the emotional undertones that accompany these mental processes. The poem also reflects on the paradoxes that often govern human emotions, particularly the intricacies of grief and joy. It does this all within the context of a seemingly simple activity-gathering flowers-a task that opens a Pandora's box of conflicting emotions and thoughts. In its brevity, the poem encapsulates the ambivalence that often accompanies recollection and forgetting, happiness and sorrow.

The poem starts with a complex notion: "If recollecting were forgetting, / Then I remember not." Here, Dickinson plays with the paradoxes of memory and forgetting. If to remember is actually to forget, then the speaker claims a state of non-remembrance. This paradoxical statement opens the door to considering the relativity of emotional and cognitive experiences. What we think we remember might not be an act of remembrance but a form of forgetting, and vice versa. This also interrogates the reliability and fallibility of human memory itself.

The next lines, "And if forgetting, recollecting, / How near I had forgot!" follow a similar vein. They explore the notion that the act of forgetting could be intricately tied to that of remembering. The speaker reflects on the closeness to which she had come to forgetting, implying that the act of recalling is itself a form of forgetfulness. These lines, like the ones before them, twist conventional understandings of memory and forgetting, inviting the reader to ponder how the two might be more interconnected than they appear.

In the second stanza, the speaker expands this paradoxical framework to emotions: "And if to miss were merry, / And if to mourn were gay." Here, the poem suggests that sadness could be a form of happiness and mourning a type of joy. It emphasizes the complexity of human emotions, which are often not as straightforward as they seem. For example, the act of mourning can bring with it not just sadness but also a form of catharsis or even joyous memories of a person or time gone by.

The poem closes with, "How very blithe the fingers / That gathered these to-day!" Here, "these" presumably refers to the flowers mentioned in the poem's title. The gathering of flowers becomes a multifaceted symbol-perhaps of memories, of lost times, or of emotions. Given the paradoxes laid out in the poem, the "blithe fingers" are tinged with both happiness and sadness, capturing the dualities that pervade the acts of remembering, forgetting, missing, and mourning.

Historically, Dickinson lived in an era marked by rigid social conventions and existential questions about life, death, and the human psyche. Her reclusive nature allowed her to delve deep into the intricacies of these universal themes. "With Flowers," therefore, can be seen as her internal dialogue with the contradictions and complexities that make up human experience.

In summary, Emily Dickinson's "With Flowers" serves as an intricate exploration of the complexities and paradoxes of human memory and emotion. In examining the interconnectedness of remembering and forgetting, of missing and mourning, the poem presents a nuanced view of the human mind. Through the simple yet potent symbol of gathering flowers, it captures the ambivalent feelings that often accompany the acts of recollection and emotional expression, offering a profound look into the convoluted landscapes of memory and emotion.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...