Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Paul Laurence Dunbar, a prominent African American poet, unveils a compelling exploration of human duality and the art of persuasion in his poem "The Lawyer's Ways." Through a unique structure, intricate style, and thought-provoking thematic content, Dunbar delves into the complexities of human nature, the power of language, and the interplay between good and evil.

Background: Born in 1872, Dunbar was a trailblazing literary figure who defied racial barriers through his mastery of both African American vernacular and traditional poetic forms. Known for his ability to capture the nuances of human experiences, Dunbar's works often resonated with themes of identity, social injustice, and inner struggles.

Analysis: "The Lawyer's Ways" presents a courtroom scene, wherein two lawyers present contrasting portrayals of the defendant. Through the unique rhyme scheme (ABCBDEFE), Dunbar creates a rhythmic exchange reminiscent of legal discourse. This structure draws readers into the persuasive battle between the lawyers, mirroring the give-and-take dynamics of a trial. The alternating rhyme pattern not only reflects the tension in the courtroom but also accentuates the juxtaposition of the lawyers' arguments.

Dunbar's style combines colloquial language and poetic sophistication, exemplified by phrases like "deep-dyed sin" and "human grace." This fusion of styles heightens the authenticity of the narrative while allowing for profound emotional expression. The first lawyer paints the defendant with vivid imagery, characterizing them as steeped in "blackest crime" and "thick grime." Conversely, the second lawyer employs emotionally charged language, using "tearful eyes" and "human grace" to elicit empathy. This stylistic contrast underscores the lawyers' mastery in manipulating emotions through language.

At the heart of the poem lies the exploration of human duality. Dunbar questions, "How an angel and a devil / Can possess the self-same soul?" This inquiry delves into the complexities of the human psyche, challenging the traditional notions of morality. By presenting the defendant as both an "angel" and a "devil," Dunbar emphasizes the coexistence of light and darkness within an individual. This theme resonates with Dunbar's broader examination of identity and the multifaceted aspects of humanity, highlighting his concern for how society often simplifies complex individuals into binary categories.

Historical and Cultural Context: "The Lawyer's Ways" reflects the socio-cultural context of Dunbar's era, a time characterized by racial tensions and legal disparities. As an African American poet, Dunbar was acutely aware of the power dynamics within the legal system and the role of language in shaping perceptions. Through the lawyers' contrasting arguments, Dunbar subtly critiques the manipulation of truth for personal gain, shedding light on the injustices prevalent in society.

Conclusion: Paul Laurence Dunbar's "The Lawyer's Ways" is a masterful exploration of language's persuasive prowess and the intricacies of human nature. The poem's structure, style, and thematic depth intertwine to create a thought-provoking narrative that challenges conventional notions of morality. By inviting readers to ponder the coexistence of good and evil within the same individual, Dunbar's work remains a timeless reflection on the complexities of the human soul. Through its exploration of duality, Dunbar's poem calls upon us to recognize the multifaceted nature of humanity and the influence of language in shaping our perceptions

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...