Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"The College Colonel" is a poem written by Herman Melville, an American author and poet, in 1866. Melville was known for his exploration of themes such as power, hierarchy, and social norms, and this poem is one of his most notable works in that vein. It reflects on the tension between individuality and conformity, as well as the limitations and dangers of blind obedience to authority.

Context:

To fully understand "The College Colonel," it is important to consider the historical and cultural context in which it was written. At the time, America was experiencing rapid industrialization and urbanization, as well as growing social and political tensions. Melville's poem can be seen as a reflection of these tensions and as a commentary on the limitations and dangers of blind obedience to authority.

Content:

The central theme of "The College Colonel" is the tension between individuality and conformity, particularly as embodied by the college colonel. The poem is written as a description of a group of college students who are blindly obedient to their colonel, despite his questionable leadership and authority. Melville uses vivid imagery and powerful language to convey the sense of tension and unease that the situation creates, as well as the dangers of blind obedience to authority.

 It is also possible to interpret "The College Colonel" as a satire, as it uses humor, irony, and exaggeration to criticize and expose the follies and shortcomings of a particular group or institution. In this case, Melville is satirizing the blind obedience and conformity of the college students under the leadership of the colonel, highlighting the dangers of such behavior and questioning the legitimacy of the colonel's authority. However, the poem can also be read as a serious commentary on the limitations of authority and the importance of individuality and critical thinking. Ultimately, the interpretation of whether the poem is a satire or not depends on the reader's perspective and understanding of the poem's themes and messages

Form:

"The College Colonel" is a rhymed poem with a regular meter and stanzas. The rhyme scheme is ABAB, CDCD, EFEF, and GG, which gives the poem a musical quality and contributes to its emotional impact. The use of repetition, such as in the repeated phrase "The Colonel" and the repeated use of the word "drill," also adds to the poem's structure and rhythm.

Poetic Elements:

Melville employs several poetic techniques and devices to convey the theme and emotions of the poem. These include figurative language, imagery, and symbolism. For example, the use of the metaphor "And he makes them climb to the eagle's nest / To take a young one from the mother's breast" emphasizes the cruel and arbitrary nature of the colonel's authority, as well as the sense of violence and brutality that underlies his leadership. Similarly, the repeated use of the word "drill" creates a sense of monotony and oppression that reinforces the poem's central theme of blind conformity and obedience.

Summary:

Overall, "The College Colonel" is a powerful and thought-provoking poem that effectively conveys the dangers of blind obedience to authority. Melville's use of poetic devices and his vivid descriptions of the colonel's leadership style adds to the emotional impact of the poem and helps to emphasize its central themes. The poem also serves as a commentary on the limitations and dangers of conformity and the importance of individuality and critical thinking in the face of authority. However, some critics may argue that the poem presents a simplistic and one-sided view of authority and obedience, overlooking the benefits and necessity of discipline and order in society. Nonetheless, "The College Colonel" remains an important and influential work in American literature and a testament to the enduring power of Melville's vision and imagination.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...