Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Louis Simpson's poem "A Story About Chicken Soup" is a poignant exploration of memory, loss, and the struggle to reconcile the past with the present. Through a mix of personal reflection, historical trauma, and striking imagery, Simpson delves into the complexities of identity, heritage, and the weight of historical memory.

The poem begins in a domestic and intimate setting: "In my grandmother's house there was always / chicken soup / And talk of the old country." The chicken soup here is more than just food; it symbolizes warmth, comfort, and a connection to the past. The "old country" represents a place of origin, steeped in memories of hardship—"mud and boards, / Poverty, / The snow falling down the necks of lovers." These images evoke a sense of nostalgia mixed with sorrow, as the past is remembered as both a place of love and of suffering.

Simpson introduces the idea of the grandmother sending "a dowry" to the old country, a gesture of support for those left behind. The mention of "The rice-powdered faces!" adds a sensory detail that bridges the cultural distance, bringing to life the tradition and the care involved in preparing for marriage. However, this image of continuity and cultural preservation is abruptly shattered with the stark reality: "But the Germans killed them." This line is jarring in its bluntness, breaking the nostalgic reverie with the harsh truth of the Holocaust.

The poem acknowledges the discomfort of speaking this truth—"I know it's in bad taste to say it, / But it's true"—yet insists on its necessity. The straightforwardness of this statement contrasts with the more poetic and gentle descriptions that precede it, highlighting the brutality of the history that interrupts the flow of memory and tradition.

Simpson then shifts to a scene in the aftermath of the war, in the ruins of Berchtesgaden, where a "child with yellow hair / Ran out of a doorway." This "German girl-child" represents innocence amid the devastation. The description of her as "Cuckoo, all skin and bones — / Not even enough to make chicken soup" juxtaposes the earlier image of nourishing soup with the reality of starvation and deprivation. The girl's innocence and vulnerability evoke sympathy, and the speaker reflects on the paradox of forgiving her: "We had killed her mechanical brothers, / So we forgave her." This line speaks to the complex emotions involved in confronting the enemy's humanity, especially when that enemy is a child who has also suffered.

The poem then transitions to a broader reflection on the lingering shadows of the past: "The sun is shining. / The shadows of the lovers have disappeared." The shadows, perhaps representing the memories of those who perished, have faded, but their legacy remains, exerting a "demand" on the speaker. These figures from the past want the speaker to "be more serious" and to immerse himself in their world of suffering: "They want me to stick in their mudhole / Where no one is elegant." The mudhole symbolizes the inescapable weight of history, the desire of the dead for the living to carry forward their memory and their pain.

However, the speaker resists this pull: "They want me to be poor, to sleep in a room with many others — / Not to walk in the painted sunshine / To a summer house, / But to live in the tragic world forever." This tension between the tragic past and the possibility of a brighter present is central to the poem. The "painted sunshine" and "summer house" represent a desire for beauty, comfort, and a life unburdened by the tragedies of history. Yet, the speaker is caught between honoring the past and embracing the present, between the obligation to remember and the desire to live fully.

In "A Story About Chicken Soup," Louis Simpson navigates the delicate balance between memory and survival, between the haunting weight of historical trauma and the human urge to seek joy and light. The poem's layered imagery and shifting tones capture the complexity of this struggle, ultimately reflecting the ongoing challenge of living in the present while carrying the past within us. Simpson's work invites readers to consider how we negotiate our relationship with history, the importance of memory, and the possibility of finding peace amid the shadows of loss.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...