Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Louis Simpson’s "Carentan O Carentan" is a haunting exploration of the brutality of war, set against the backdrop of the French town of Carentan, which became infamous during World War II for the fierce battles that took place there. Simpson, a soldier himself during the war, uses this poem to juxtapose the peaceful, almost idyllic past of the town with the violent, chaotic reality of combat, capturing the tragic transformation of a place and the devastating impact on those who experience it.

The poem opens with a nostalgic reflection on what Carentan once was—a place of tranquility and romance. "Trees in the old days used to stand / And shape a shady lane / Where lovers wandered hand in hand / Who came from Carentan." These lines evoke a pastoral scene, filled with the peacefulness of a bygone era. The imagery of lovers walking hand in hand under a canopy of trees suggests a time when Carentan was synonymous with love and life. This peacefulness is sharply contrasted with the subsequent image of soldiers, "walking at combat-interval," who have replaced the lovers. The trees that once shaped a shady lane for lovers are now witnesses to war, and the soldiers, marching two by two, are painfully aware that such trees were "never knew" in their war-torn reality.

Simpson continues to build this contrast throughout the poem, using the serene imagery of nature—"the ground / Was soft and bright with dew," "the sky was blue"—to emphasize the jarring presence of war. The calmness of the setting is punctuated by distant sounds of guns and the ominous "smoke / Hung still above the sea." These descriptions underscore the tension between the natural beauty of the landscape and the destructive force of war that looms over it.

As the poem progresses, Simpson introduces the theme of death with increasing intensity. The shift from the serene to the sinister is gradual but relentless. The "watchers in their leopard suits," a reference to enemy soldiers in camouflage, introduce the first real threat, as they "waited till it was time" to attack. The violence is depicted with brutal simplicity—"aimed between the belt and boot / And let the barrel climb." The cold efficiency of the enemy, combined with the inevitability of death, is palpable.

The poem then turns deeply personal as the speaker expresses a moment of fear and resignation. "I must lie down at once, there is / A hammer at my knee. / And call it death or cowardice, / Don’t count again on me." This moment is profoundly human, capturing the vulnerability and the helplessness of a soldier in the face of overwhelming odds. The reference to "Mother" in the following stanza adds a layer of poignancy, as the speaker tries to rationalize his fate—"Everything’s all right, Mother, / Everyone gets the same / At one time or another. / It’s all in the game." The casual acceptance of death as "part of the game" is both heartbreaking and reflective of the desensitization that soldiers often experience.

The poem concludes with a return to the imagery of Carentan, but now the town is irrevocably changed. The refrain "Carentan O Carentan" resonates with a sense of loss and sorrow. The speaker laments that they never experienced the simple joys of life—"I never strolled, nor ever shall, / Down such a leafy lane. / I never drank in a canal, / Nor ever shall again." The repetition of "never shall" underscores the finality of war’s impact, not just on the town, but on the soldiers themselves.

The final stanzas convey a sense of disillusionment and abandonment. The speaker’s calls for guidance—to the Sergeant, Captain, and Lieutenant—are met with silence. These figures of authority, who once provided direction and purpose, are now "silent," "sickly," or "sleeping," symbolizing the futility of seeking order in the chaos of war. The poem ends on a note of grim realization: "Before we met with you / We never yet had lost a man / Or known what death could do." The encounter with Carentan is not just a loss of life, but a loss of innocence and an introduction to the true horrors of war.

"Carentan O Carentan" is a powerful elegy for a time and place destroyed by war, as well as for the soldiers who were irrevocably changed by it. Through vivid imagery and poignant reflections, Louis Simpson captures the tragic transformation of Carentan and the devastating impact of war on the human soul. The poem is a sobering reminder of the cost of conflict and the fragile nature of peace.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...