Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Wis?awa Szymborska's "Hitler's First Photograph" is a chilling exploration of the banality of evil, scrutinizing the innocuous beginnings of Adolf Hitler. With a tone that juxtaposes the ghastly events that we know will unfold with the normalcy of a newborn's arrival, Szymborska presents an uncanny dissonance that forces us to confront uncomfortable questions about the nature of evil and destiny.

The poem opens with a seemingly whimsical question: "And who's this little fellow in his itty-bitty robe?" The tone is deceptively light, reminiscent of the cooing language people often use when talking about babies. It is only when the baby is named "tiny baby Adolf" that the tension begins to settle in. The juxtaposition of the sweet tone with the sinister historical context creates a deeply unsettling atmosphere. We are immediately forced to wrestle with the notion that this monster-in-the-making was once a 'precious little angel,' invoking an uneasy cognitive dissonance that lingers throughout the poem.

Questions about Adolf's future pepper the first stanza. Will he become a doctor or a tenor? It seems almost cruel to consider such benign fates for someone whose name would become synonymous with genocide and cruelty. Szymborska deliberately lays out these scenarios to challenge the reader. She forces us to ponder how a seemingly average child could become an agent of unprecedented horror. By doing this, she implicates society at large: is evil born or is it made? And if it is made, then what role do we all play in its making?

As the poem progresses, it describes a world blissfully unaware of the darkness that has just been born into it. "Spring sun, geraniums in windows, the organ-grinder's music in the yard" - all these signs of life and renewal contrast sharply with the doom that we know will follow. Even his mother's dream of a dove, traditionally a symbol of peace, is turned on its head. Here, the bird portends the arrival of a "long-awaited guest" who will bring anything but "joyful news."

The poem then zooms out to describe the town of Braunau, characterized as 'small, but worthy.' Businesses are 'honest,' neighbors 'obliging,' and the smells are those of 'yeast dough' and 'gray soap,' all contributing to an air of normalcy. Yet it's this very normalcy that makes the poem so harrowing. Braunau becomes a metaphor for any town; the people in it could be any people. No one hears "howling dogs, or fate's footsteps," suggesting that evil can grow just as easily in the most mundane of settings, undetected until it is too late.

By focusing on Hitler's first photograph, Szymborska makes a profound statement about the inscrutable origins of evil. We are left grappling with the question: how could someone so monstrous arise from circumstances so painfully ordinary? The photograph, fixed in time, leaves us in a state of timeless reflection, pondering the weighty issues of destiny, the human capacity for evil, and the social conditions that allow such malevolence to flourish. Through haunting juxtapositions and unsettling details, the poem ultimately serves as a grim reminder of the complexities of human nature, forcing us to consider the potential for evil that exists in all seemingly innocent beginnings."

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...