Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Stupid Meditation on Peace" by Robert Pinsky is an intellectually charged poem that navigates the complex terrain of peace, love, and human behavior. The poem begins with a quote from Gerard Manley Hopkins, "He does not come to coo," which serves as a frame to discuss the ideas of peace and love symbolized by the dove. The juxtaposition of these themes forms the central axis around which the poem spins its narrative.

At first glance, the term "stupid" in the title appears almost ironic; the poem is anything but lacking in intellectual rigor. The poem seeks to scrutinize our idealized notions of peace by unpacking them through biological, psychological, and even cosmological lenses. It contemplates the contradictory human attributes that enable both creation and destruction, questioning the very notion of peace as a universal good.

Pinsky employs the term "monkey-mind," a Buddhist term describing an unsettled, restless, or confused mental state, to represent the erratic human thinking process. This choice is indicative of the poem's contemplative nature, as it ponders the complexities of human love and war. Here, sexual love is linked to biological imperatives. In the process of mating and reproduction, the human male is "expendable," "rash," and "reckless." On the contrary, the dove is held up as an ideal: both male and female "secrete Pigeon milk for the young from his throat," embodying a kind of egalitarian nurturing absent in humans.

Pinsky's suggestion of sending "all human males between / Fourteen and twenty-five to school / On the Moon, or better yet Mars," is hyperbolic but captures the desperation to find a solution to human destructiveness. However, the poem also recognizes that women and older men are not exempt from causing "Unpeace," and thus complicates any easy answers.

In one of the most intriguing parts of the poem, a comic's perspective on life's journey introduces the idea that one must choose between the "River of Peace" and the "River of Productivity." Art is located in the more volatile, industrious stream, challenging the notion that art and peace are inextricably linked. This is a subtle critique of the idealized, romanticized view of art as being always peace-inducing or beautiful; sometimes it must engage with the messy, the noisy, the turbulent.

Finally, the poem debates whether peace is simply the absence of war or a "positive energy." It struggles with this definition, just as it struggles with the dualities presented throughout. Despite the teachings that advocate for peace as something active and affirmative, the poem concludes on a note of resistance, likening the mind to a restless, inferior cousin "Who fires his shit in handfuls from his cage."

In its layered narrative and complex philosophical wanderings, "Stupid Meditation on Peace" offers no easy answers. Instead, it invites the reader into a space of ambiguity and contradiction, urging a more nuanced understanding of human nature and the elusive quest for peace.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...