Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In Sylvia Plath's "Dialogue Between Ghost and Priest," a conversation unfolds in a rectory garden between Father Shawn and a ghostly figure. The setting is described as cold and somber, capturing the essence of "black November." The atmosphere is filled with mist, which the ghost materializes from, and the imagery of dew standing "in chill sweat on each stalk, each thorn," is a harbinger of the mysterious encounter that follows. This spectral setting imbues the poem with an aura of the mystical, which acts as the backdrop for a philosophical discussion on the nature of the soul, love, and the afterlife.

Father Shawn, somewhat brisk and matter-of-fact, queries the ghost about its origin. His question is deeply existential, probing into the ghost's previous life, whether it hails from heaven or the "frozen waste of hell." The ghost, speaking "in a voice furred with frost," avoids these dichotomies, stating that its haunt is Earth, not heaven or hell. This underscores the idea that the boundaries between life and death, divine and earthly, are not as clear-cut as they might seem; it also suggests that the ghost is trapped in a liminal space.

The poem challenges conventional religious beliefs about the afterlife. Father Shawn, who embodies traditional religious authority, is shocked at the ghost's refusal to abide by his binary understanding of heaven and hell. He accuses the ghost of clinging to its earthly existence and admonishes it to go to a "higher court of grace." The ghost's rebuttal is thought-provoking: "There sits no higher court than man's red heart." This line disrupts the power dynamics in the poem, questioning the concept of ultimate judgment and suggesting that the highest authority might lie within human emotion, specifically love, rather than in an institutionalized religious understanding of the afterlife.

Love, in this poem, is a double-edged sword. It is what gnawed the ghost's skin "to this white bone" in life and continues to gnaw "me through" in death. Love serves both as a form of torment and as the ghost's raison d'être. Father Shawn interprets this as a cautionary tale against excessive love for the "flawed earth-flesh," but the ghost corrects him, saying that the "day of doom is not yet come." This could imply that the ghost's condition is not yet final and might be subject to change, or that love-both its pain and its beauty-is an eternal state.

The poem is complex in its exploration of themes like existentialism, the ambiguity of afterlife, and the omnipotence of love. It pits traditional religious authority against individual experience, thereby questioning the strict religious doctrines that offer a black-and-white view of existence and non-existence. Plath masterfully engages in a dialogue that is both intimate and universal, reflecting on some of the most fundamental questions of human existence. In doing so, she suggests that perhaps the most meaningful aspects of life-and death-cannot be easily defined or contained within conventional religious narratives.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...