Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Letter to a Purist," penned by Sylvia Plath, constructs a love letter unlike any other-a love letter to a contradiction, to a lover who exists between the earthy and the ethereal. Employing vivid images and ironic comparisons, Plath explores the paradoxes of love, imperfection, and human vulnerability in a few concentrated lines. Her fascination with contradiction is front and center, not just in the subject, whom she calls both "O my love" and "O my great idiot," but also in the oppositional forces that tug at him.

The poem begins by invoking a "grandiose colossus," likely an allusion to the Colossus of Rhodes, one of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World. This giant statue is depicted as resisting the "envious assaults of sea," standing unyielding against the force of nature. Immediately following this grand imagery, Plath asserts, "Has nothing on you," implying that the lover in question surpasses even this legendary figure in some essential way. The paradox arises instantly: How could an 'idiot,' caught in the 'muck-trap' of mortality, be more significant than a grandiose monument?

The lover is described as having "one foot / Caught (as it were) in the muck-trap / Of skin and bone," signaling a deeply human, earthly existence. The "muck-trap" is an explicit symbol of the physical limitations and the inherent imperfections that come with being human. Yet, the other foot "Dithers with the other way out / In preposterous provinces of the madcap / Cloud-cuckoo," suggesting an aspirational, even foolish, reach towards something higher, perhaps spiritual or idealistic. "Dithers" is a particularly apt choice of verb, encapsulating a sense of indecision and nervous energy, indicative of the lover's own inner conflict between earthly pull and spiritual aspiration.

The phrase "Cloud-cuckoo" offers another interesting layer to the poem. Cloud-cuckoo-land is an idiom derived from Aristophanes' play "The Birds," denoting an unrealistically idealistic state where everything is perfect. By placing one foot there, the lover seems permanently suspended between the real and the unreal, the rational and the absurd.

Yet, the poem's conclusion, "Agawp at the impeccable moon," seems to capture a moment of purity and clarity amidst the contradictions. The moon has been a symbol of many things-romance, lunacy, change-but here it appears to signify something untouchable and 'impeccable,' perhaps an ideal form of love or understanding that both the speaker and her lover strive to comprehend, however imperfectly.

The structure of "Letter to a Purist" by Sylvia Plath is a significant element in conveying its thematic depth. Consisting of a single stanza with varying line lengths, the poem defies traditional forms. This structural choice could be seen as a reflection of the contradictions and complexities within the subject matter itself. The form doesn't conform to conventional models, much like the lover described in the poem. The structure of the poem serves as a rich interpretive field where the themes of contradiction, tension, and complexity are not just stated but also enacted. Through its unconventional form, varied line lengths, and the use of enjambment, the poem encapsulates the mercurial nature of human love, rendering a portrait that is, much like its subject, irresistibly flawed and infinitely intriguing.

In this short but evocative poem, Sylvia Plath captures the conflicting drives that exist within human love and aspiration. We are, she suggests, all purists at heart, yearning for something beyond our reach, while mired in our unavoidable human flaws. But it is in this very tension, this dithering between the earth and the sky, that we find our unique grandeur. The contradictions don't weaken us; they define us. Even the grandiose Colossus, fixed in its monumental certainties, "Has nothing on you," in your bewildering, frustrating, and utterly human complexity.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...