Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Charles Reznikoff's poem "Romance" presents a stark and ironic depiction of the idealized notion of war, contrasting the perceived nobility of battle with the grim realities that lie beneath this romanticized veneer. The poem uses the imagery of cleanliness and purity to explore the tension between the glorified vision of war and the harsh, dirty truth of what it entails.

The poem begins with a repetitive and rhythmic line: "The troopers are riding, are riding by / the troopers are riding to kill and die." The repetition of "are riding" emphasizes the steady, relentless march of soldiers into battle, creating a sense of inevitability and duty. The phrase "to kill and die" brings the harsh reality of war into sharp focus, stripping away any illusions of heroism and reducing the act of war to its most basic and brutal elements: killing and being killed.

The poem’s central irony lies in the phrase "that a clean flag may cleanly fly." Here, the flag symbolizes the ideals and values for which the troopers are supposedly fighting—honor, patriotism, and purity. The adjective "clean" is repeated, suggesting a desire for moral clarity and righteousness in the cause of war. However, the very need for soldiers to "kill and die" to achieve this cleanliness suggests a contradiction. The flag may be clean, but the means by which it is kept flying are anything but. This line challenges the romantic notion that war can be noble or pure, implying that the bloodshed and violence required to maintain a nation’s ideals inevitably taint those very ideals.

In the second stanza, Reznikoff continues to explore this theme of cleanliness. The troopers "touch the dust in their homes no more," indicating that they have left behind the mundane, dirty aspects of civilian life—symbolized by the dust, shop, and store—to engage in something supposedly higher and more noble. They are now "clean of the dirt of shop and store," suggesting that by going to war, they have purified themselves of the trivial concerns of everyday life. The line "and they ride out clean to war" reinforces this idea, presenting war as a purifying force that elevates the soldiers above the grime of civilian existence.

However, the poem’s use of the word "clean" becomes increasingly ironic as it progresses. The notion that war can cleanse or purify is deeply flawed, as the reality of war is one of blood, dirt, and death. The "clean" departure of the soldiers contrasts sharply with the dirty, violent, and ultimately destructive nature of war. The soldiers may ride out with the illusion of cleanliness and moral clarity, but the inevitable outcome of war is anything but clean.

Reznikoff’s "Romance" uses the language of purity and cleanliness to critique the romanticized view of war. The poem suggests that the ideal of a "clean flag" flying over a nation is a dangerous illusion, one that requires the sacrifice of human lives and the embrace of violence. The troopers, in their quest for this ideal, are themselves caught in the contradiction between the noble ideals they believe they are fighting for and the brutal, dirty reality of the conflict they engage in.

In just a few lines, Reznikoff captures the dissonance between the romantic notion of war and its grim reality. The poem serves as a powerful reminder that the glorification of war often obscures the true cost of conflict—the lives lost, the bloodshed, and the moral compromises made in the name of supposedly noble causes. "Romance" challenges the reader to question the myths of heroism and purity that are often attached to war and to see through the illusions to the harsh truths that lie beneath.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...