Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Richard Wilbur’s "Trolling for Blues" is a layered meditation on humanity’s projection of itself onto nature, using the act of fishing for bluefish as a vehicle for exploring the relationship between perception, imagination, and the primal forces of existence. Through vivid imagery and reflective tone, the poem moves seamlessly between the surface beauty of the natural world and the deeper, darker mysteries of life’s origins. Wilbur masterfully weaves together themes of intellect, instinct, and evolution, inviting readers to consider the limits of human understanding in the face of the vast and unthinking processes of nature.

The poem begins with a comparison between bluefish and other natural phenomena, such as “dapper terns” and “that sole cloud.” These entities, admired for their elegance and singularity, become mirrors for human contemplation, as the bluefish’s “fight and beauty” have similarly endeared it to the fisherman. This tendency to see nature as a reflection of ourselves sets the stage for the poem’s exploration of the human propensity to assign meaning and intellect to nonhuman forms. The fish, described as “keen,” becomes a vessel for the speaker’s musings, despite its “unreflectiveness” and instinct-driven existence.

The fish’s “flings in air” and migratory “swerve” to distant spawning grounds are acknowledged as aberrant behaviors when viewed through a human lens. Yet, as the fisherman “musing to the engine’s thrum” imagines the fish waiting below the surface, the bluefish becomes a symbol of thought and attention: “Blue in the water’s blue, which is the shade / Of thought.” This layering of blue—the fish, the water, and the shade of contemplation—merges the natural and the intellectual, suggesting a kinship between the fish’s poised state and the human capacity for reflection. The fish, weightless yet alert, is idealized as a “type of coolest intellect,” embodying precision and decisiveness in its actions.

However, this anthropomorphic vision is abruptly disrupted when the fish strikes and escapes “unseen beneath the rip.” The suddenness of its movement yanks “imagination back and down / Past recognition to the unlit deep.” Here, the poem shifts from an idealized projection of intellect to an encounter with the primal, inscrutable forces of the natural world. The depths into which the fish retreats are described as “the unlit deep / Of the glass sponges, of Chiasmodon.” These references to obscure marine life and ancient evolutionary history evoke the alien and ungraspable nature of the ocean’s abyss.

The poem’s imagery deepens as it descends into “the old darkness of Devonian dream,” a reference to the Devonian period, when life began to emerge from the primordial seas. This descent into the “unlit deep” symbolizes a return to a preconscious state, “that long mélée where selves were not.” The fish’s environment becomes a metaphor for a phase of existence that predates individuality, awareness, or intellect—a time when life was “merciless, painless, sleepless, unaware.” The description is both haunting and awe-inspiring, emphasizing the sheer alienness of life’s origins and the vast gulf between instinctive existence and human consciousness.

The poem concludes by acknowledging the unthinkable nature of humanity’s rise from these primal beginnings. The bluefish, initially perceived as a mirror of human intellect, ultimately leads the speaker to confront the limits of imagination and the mystery of life’s evolution. The fish’s world, so distant from human understanding, serves as a reminder of the unbridgeable divide between the conscious mind and the instinct-driven forces from which it emerged.

Structurally, the poem’s fluid lines and seamless transitions mirror the movement of the water and the act of fishing itself—pausing, reflecting, and diving into deeper currents of thought. Wilbur’s language is both precise and evocative, blending scientific specificity with lyrical beauty to create a meditation that is as intellectually engaging as it is emotionally resonant.

At its core, "Trolling for Blues" is an exploration of the human impulse to find meaning in nature and the limitations of such projections. The bluefish, initially idealized as a symbol of intellect and decisiveness, ultimately reveals the vast and unthinking processes of evolution that lie beyond human comprehension. Through its vivid imagery and philosophical depth, the poem captures the tension between our desire to understand and the profound mysteries that remain inaccessible, inviting readers to reflect on the delicate balance between intellect and instinct in the natural world and within ourselves.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...