Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Epitaph" by Elinor Wylie, the speaker reflects on the life of a woman who has undergone immense suffering in the pursuit of beauty and grace, only to meet an unworthy end. The poem is a meditation on the cost of perfection, the relationship between pain and transformation, and the inherent tragedy in striving for ideals that ultimately lead to a premature or unsatisfactory conclusion. Through the use of vivid imagery and metaphor, Wylie explores themes of sacrifice, physical and emotional suffering, and the hollow nature of superficial ideals.

The opening lines depict the woman’s transformation through suffering, where “she starred her eyes with salt / And scooped her temples thin.” The phrase "starred her eyes with salt" evokes an image of tears or sorrow, suggesting that the woman’s beauty is not easily attained but instead comes at the cost of emotional or physical pain. The act of "scooping her temples thin" implies a self-inflicted refinement, as if she is carving away parts of herself in order to attain an idealized form. Her face is described as "pure of fault," indicating that she has achieved a flawless appearance, but it is clear that this perfection comes at the expense of her well-being.

The second stanza shifts to describe the physical and emotional toll of her transformation. “In coldest crucibles of pain / Her shrinking flesh was fired / And smoothed into a finer grain / To make it more desired.” The metaphor of a "crucible" suggests a process of intense heat and pressure, further emphasizing the extreme nature of her suffering. The image of "shrinking flesh" conveys a sense of loss, as if her body is being whittled down or sacrificed to meet an ideal. Her "finer grain" refers to the smoothness or refinement of her form, but it is implied that this beauty is not natural or effortless—it is the result of pain and hardship, yet it is "desired" by others, pointing to the societal emphasis on external appearances.

In the next stanza, the speaker describes how pain has affected the woman’s lips and hands: “Pain left her lips more clear than glass; / It colored and cooled her hand.” Pain has, paradoxically, enhanced her features. The "clear lips" symbolize purity or perfection, while the "colored and cooled hand" suggests a balance between warmth and detachment, as if her very touch has become more refined through suffering. The contrast between the clarity of her lips and the coldness of her hands suggests that while her beauty has become transcendent and unblemished, she has lost her humanity in the process—her appearance has been perfected, but it has come at the expense of her emotional warmth and vitality.

The speaker continues, describing the woman as a “field of scented grass / Yielded as pasture land.” The metaphor of a field of grass conveys a sense of fertility, but it is also something that has been cultivated or shaped for a particular purpose. The word "yielded" suggests a sense of submission, as if she has allowed herself to be shaped and molded for others’ desires. Her body, like pasture land, has been commodified and used to satisfy the desires of others, without regard to the cost to her own sense of self.

The final stanza reflects on the irony of the woman’s fate. “For this her loveliness was curved / And carved as silver is: / For this she was brave: but she deserved / A better grave than this.” The comparison to silver emphasizes the precious, crafted nature of her beauty, suggesting that her appearance was carefully shaped and honed like a piece of fine art. Despite her bravery in enduring the pain to attain this beauty, the poem’s conclusion is one of sorrow and regret. The woman, who has sacrificed so much for an idealized beauty, is left with an "unworthy grave." The phrase "she deserved / A better grave than this" conveys the speaker's pity and disappointment in the woman's fate, implying that she should have been rewarded for her sacrifice with a more honorable or meaningful end.

“Epitaph” is a poignant reflection on the cost of societal ideals of beauty and perfection, as well as the emotional and physical toll they can take on an individual. The speaker mourns the woman’s sacrifice, recognizing that her pursuit of beauty, though brave, has led her to a tragic, unfulfilling conclusion. Through powerful imagery and metaphor, Wylie critiques the superficial standards that demand perfection at the expense of the person’s well-being, suggesting that true value lies beyond external appearance, and that such sacrifices often go unappreciated or unrewarded.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...