Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Jorge Luis Borges' poem "Soldier of Urbina" reflects on the inner life and transformation of a soldier who, feeling defeated by his experiences in battle and the harshness of reality, seeks solace in the world of imagination and dreams. Borges explores themes of identity, failure, and the power of literature to reshape and redeem one's life. The poem also serves as a subtle tribute to Miguel de Cervantes, whose life and works—especially "Don Quixote"—form the undercurrent of the soldier's journey from a life of defeat to a life of creative vision.

The poem opens by acknowledging the soldier's inability to endure "the strain / Of battles like the last he fought at sea." The soldier has been physically and emotionally defeated, unable to continue his role as a warrior. Borges contrasts this with the soldier’s eventual descent into "sordid usury," an occupation far removed from the noble, heroic ideals of battle. His fate seems tragic: he "wandered unknown throughout his own harsh Spain," evoking a sense of displacement, alienation, and a loss of purpose. This image of wandering emphasizes the soldier's aimlessness and the harshness of the world around him.

To escape the pain of his reality, the soldier turns to dreams and literature: "To blot out or to mitigate the pain / Of all reality, he hid in dream." This retreat into the imagination becomes a source of solace and redemption for the soldier. Borges suggests that the soldier finds refuge in the "magic past" of epic tales, particularly those of "Roland and the tales of Ancient Britain." These legendary stories transport the soldier away from the struggles of his present life, allowing him to immerse himself in a world of heroic feats and mythic grandeur. The reference to Roland, the knight of Charlemagne’s court, and the ancient tales of Britain, evoke the themes of chivalry, honor, and adventure that contrast sharply with the soldier's defeated state.

As the poem progresses, Borges paints a picture of the soldier contemplating the Spanish landscape at sunset: "At sunset he would contemplate the vast / Plain with its copper light lingering on." This moment of reflection, set against the backdrop of a vast, illuminated plain, suggests that the soldier, despite his sense of defeat, still finds beauty and meaning in the natural world. The image of the copper light lingering on the plain is symbolic of the lingering hope and potential for transformation that exists within the soldier.

Despite feeling "defeated, poor, alone," the soldier remains "Ignorant of what music he was master." Borges hints that the soldier possesses a creative potential, a "music" within him that he is unaware of. This "music" suggests a deeper, latent talent for storytelling or artistic expression, which he has not yet discovered or fully realized.

The poem concludes with a powerful revelation: "Already, in the still depths of some dream, / Don Quixote and Sancho were alive in him." Here, Borges links the soldier’s inner transformation to the creation of "Don Quixote", suggesting that the soldier’s imagination has already begun to give life to the characters of Cervantes’ famous novel. The soldier, in his dreams, becomes the creator of Don Quixote and Sancho, two iconic figures who embody both the tragic and the comic aspects of human existence. Don Quixote, the idealistic knight who embarks on fantastical quests, and Sancho Panza, his loyal, pragmatic squire, represent the fusion of imagination and reality that defines "Don Quixote" as a work of literature.

Through this subtle allusion to Cervantes, Borges celebrates the power of literature to transform lives. The soldier, once defeated by reality, becomes a creator of dreams and stories, giving life to characters who will endure far beyond his own lifetime. In this way, the soldier's retreat into dreams is not an act of defeat, but one of creative transcendence. Borges implies that through the act of imagining and storytelling, the soldier finds a new sense of purpose and fulfillment, one that elevates him from the mundane and painful realities of his life.

In "Soldier of Urbina," Borges masterfully blends historical allusion, literary homage, and philosophical reflection to explore the themes of failure, imagination, and artistic creation. The poem suggests that even in moments of defeat and despair, the power of dreams and literature can offer redemption and open up new possibilities for understanding oneself and the world. Borges’ meditation on the soldier’s inner transformation ultimately serves as a testament to the enduring power of the human imagination and its ability to shape and give meaning to our lives.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...