Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"For a Man Who Speaks with Birds" by Toi Derricotte is a deeply evocative poem that explores the themes of vulnerability, isolation, and the yearning for authentic connection in a world that often values strength and authority over sensitivity and communication with nature. Through the metaphor of a man who literally and figuratively speaks with birds, Derricotte delves into the complex interplay between societal expectations and personal identity.

The poem opens with the image of the man wearing his body uncomfortably, likened to a boy in oversized football pads. This simile immediately sets a tone of unease and displacement, highlighting the discrepancy between the persona he presents to the world and his true self. The mention of "old football pads of boyhood" suggests a lingering attachment to past expectations of masculinity that no longer fit, causing him to feel trapped in a role that is both confining and alienating.

As the poem progresses, the man is depicted as a leader chosen by businessmen, an outward symbol of success and authority. Yet, this external achievement contrasts sharply with his inner desire "to speak to the redbirds," a metaphor for a deep-seated longing to connect with something pure, natural, and transcendent beyond the materialistic and competitive world of business.

The imagery of being "stuck between floors pushing all the dead buttons" further illustrates the man's feeling of entrapment and frustration in his attempts to escape the confines of his imposed identity. His ability to mimic the "whistles of redbirds" suggests a hidden talent and sensitivity that is at odds with the persona he must maintain in public life.

Derricotte's use of the king and slave analogy underscores the power dynamics at play, with the man's eyes knowing "how to look from a great height," yet his heart remains aligned with the natural and the free, symbolized by the redbirds. This duality reflects the tension between the roles we are forced to play and the authentic selves we suppress in the process.

The poem closes with a poignant reflection on the man's internal struggle, carrying "a satchel of orders from devil to devil" while his heart yearns to express itself in the "tongues of red angels." This imagery speaks to the existential battle between conforming to societal demands and honoring one's true nature and desires.

"For a Man Who Speaks with Birds" is a powerful meditation on the costs of societal conformity, the sacrifices of personal identity, and the universal quest for meaning and connection in a world that often overlooks the value of simplicity, nature, and genuine communication. Derricotte's poem invites readers to reflect on their own experiences of alienation and the moments of beauty and liberation that can be found in connecting with the natural world and embracing one's true self.

POEM TEXT: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/57820/my-dad-sardines

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...