Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Birago Diop's poem "Vanity" is a profound meditation on the themes of legacy, memory, and the disconnect between the living and the dead. The poem explores the idea that the voices of past generations—filled with wisdom, pain, and warnings—often go unheard by their descendants, who remain oblivious to the lessons and experiences left behind. Through vivid imagery and a tone that oscillates between sorrow and admonishment, Diop delves into the consequences of ignoring the knowledge and sacrifices of those who came before us.

The poem begins with a poignant and gentle plea: "If we tell, gently, gently / All that we shall one day have to tell." This line suggests that there are truths and stories that must eventually be shared, but the manner in which they are conveyed is crucial. The repetition of "gently, gently" underscores the sensitivity required in addressing these deep and potentially painful truths. However, the poem immediately questions whether these truths will be received with the seriousness they deserve: "Who then will hear our voices without laughter, / Sad complaining voices of beggars / Who indeed will hear them without laughter?"

Here, Diop captures the fear that the voices of those who have suffered or been marginalized—reduced to "beggars"—will be dismissed or ridiculed. The "sad complaining voices" represent the cries of the oppressed, the forgotten, and the ignored, whose experiences are at risk of being trivialized. The repetition of the question about laughter emphasizes the poet's concern that these voices will not be taken seriously, that their suffering will be met with mockery rather than empathy.

The poem continues to explore this theme of dismissal and ignorance: "If we cry roughly of our torments / Ever increasing from the start of things, / What eyes will watch our large mouths / Shaped by the laughter of big children?" This imagery highlights the futility of expressing anguish when the world is indifferent or even amused by such expressions. The "large mouths" shaped by laughter suggest that even the most intense cries of pain are often met with a lack of understanding or concern, as if the sufferings of the past and present are nothing more than the antics of children.

Diop then poses a series of rhetorical questions that further emphasize this disconnect: "What heart will listen to our clamouring? / What ear to our pitiful anger / Which grows in us like a tumour / In the black depth of our plaintive throats?" The imagery here is stark and visceral, with the "tumour" representing the festering anger and sorrow that build up inside those who feel unheard. The "black depth of our plaintive throats" conveys a sense of deep-seated grief and frustration, as if the cries of the marginalized are choked and suppressed, unable to find a sympathetic listener.

The poem then shifts to address the relationship between the living and the dead: "When our Dead come with their Dead / When they have spoken to us with their clumsy voices." The "Dead" are depicted as returning to communicate with the living, but their voices are "clumsy"—perhaps awkward, difficult to understand, or ignored altogether. This reflects the idea that the wisdom and warnings of past generations are often neglected or misunderstood by the living.

Diop poignantly reflects on how the living have been "deaf / To their cries, to their wild appeals," highlighting a generational disconnect. The dead have "left on the earth their cries," which linger "in the air, on the water, where they have traced their signs." These "signs" are the legacies, lessons, and memories left behind, yet the "blind deaf and unworthy Sons" fail to recognize or heed them. The speaker laments that these signs, so carefully traced by the dead, go unnoticed by their descendants.

The poem's concluding lines return to the earlier themes of despair and futility: "And since we did not understand our dead / Since we have never listened to their cries - / If we weep, gently, gently / If we cry roughly of our torments / What heart will listen to our clamouring, / What ear to our sobbing hearts?" These lines reinforce the idea that if the living continue to ignore the voices of the past, they too will find their own cries and sorrows dismissed or ignored. The repetition of "gently, gently" and "cry roughly" suggests that whether the expression is soft or forceful, it may still fall on deaf ears.

In "Vanity," Birago Diop masterfully explores the consequences of generational disconnect and the failure to heed the wisdom of the past. The poem is a poignant reflection on how easily the experiences and sacrifices of those who came before can be forgotten or trivialized. Diop warns that this negligence is not without consequence—if the living continue to ignore the voices of the dead, their own voices may one day be met with the same indifference. The poem serves as a reminder of the importance of memory, respect, and understanding across generations, urging us to listen to and learn from the legacies of those who have gone before us.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...