Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Retreating Wind" by Louise Gluck offers a perspective that is simultaneously divine and maternal, examining the tensions between creation, love, and disappointment. The poem is structured as a monologue from a creator to its creations, wherein the creator initially feels love but eventually pities its creations for their limitations and perceived failings. In this portrayal, the creator's relationship with its creations appears deeply intimate yet fraught with emotional complexity.

The poem begins with a stark juxtaposition between past love and present pity: "When I made you, I loved you. / Now I pity you." This sets the stage for the emotional and ethical quandary that unfolds. The creator claims to have provided all the essentials, a "bed of earth, blanket of blue air," and yet, as the creator distances itself, there's a realization that its creations have not lived up to their potential. Here, distance serves as a lens that sharpens the focus, allowing for a more objective assessment.

The phrase "Your souls should have been immense by now" underscores the creator's disappointment. It implies an evolutionary or developmental failing. Instead of growing and expanding, the souls remain "small talking things," trivial and mundane. This indictment reveals a heartrending contrast between the creator's initial hope and the final outcome.

One of the most striking lines is, "I gave you every gift, / blue of the spring morning, / time you didn't know how to use." This feels almost like an accusation, emphasizing human inadequacy in the face of divine generosity. There's a sense of squandered potential, an existential restlessness encapsulated in "you wanted more, the one gift / reserved for another creation." Whether this refers to immortality, ultimate wisdom, or some other unknowable gift is left tantalizingly unclear. It echoes the biblical idea of forbidden knowledge, the elusive "more" that led to mankind's expulsion from Eden.

In stark contrast to the plant world, human lives are not described as "circular." They are more akin to a "bird's flight / which begins and ends in stillness." This image is fraught with poetic grace, but it's also tinged with melancholy. The arc of human life, unlike the recurring cycles of nature, has a finality to it, "beginning and ending in stillness." The poem concludes with an elegant image that closes the thematic loop: "this arc from the white birch / to the apple tree." The specific trees mentioned provide an earthly grounding to the lofty themes, perhaps symbolizing stages of human life or distinct moments of clarity and fruitfulness.

"Retreating Wind" confronts us with the dissonance between what is given and what is ultimately made of those gifts. It presents a divine or maternal lament, a sorrowful reckoning with creation's limitations. This is the essence of Gluck's brilliance: she takes broad, sweeping themes and distills them into moments that are intensely personal, thereby inviting the reader to partake in the emotional and philosophical complexities that the poem brings to the surface.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...