Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

"Doppelganger" by Jane Hirshfield grapples with the complexities of human choices, emotional attachments, and the ever-present parallel realities that come to define our lives. It is a poem that navigates the knotty terrain of "faithfulness" and its consequences, both enlightening and brutal.

The poem opens with the phrase "The old knot," setting a tone of longstanding, deeply ingrained complexity. The notion of cleaving is dual, meaning both to cut apart and to adhere closely, presenting a paradox that aptly captures the intricate dimensions of human relationships and commitments. "Cleave to this," the poem commands, almost as if advising to stick to a decision, a relationship, or a path. Yet, it immediately contradicts itself by stating that "all faithfulness, cuts at the heart." Here, Hirshfield captures the painful truth that the act of remaining true to something or someone is itself a sort of wounding, limiting other possibilities and closing doors.

The phrase "that wreckage carved out by choice, the heart" is particularly poignant. It asserts that every choice we make contributes to the "wreckage" that is the emotional and experiential landscape of our lives. The heart itself becomes a monument to past decisions, filled with scars and hollows.

The poem then transitions to another form of cleaving-"cleave this-whatever is split." Here, the term "cleave" takes on its second meaning, to separate or divide. Hirshfield reminds us that every decision or relationship carries its shadow, its "doppelganger," if you will. The poem proposes that whatever path we take, an alternate one always exists, haunting us with its "yellow leaves falling and falling / in the steep woods of our hundred other." This is an incredibly evocative metaphor for regret, nostalgia, or even simple curiosity about the road not taken, described as a continual, autumnal shedding in a separate, hidden forest of what might have been.

The free-verse form of the poem and the absence of punctuation other than parentheses and ampersands contribute to a sense of breathless urgency and open-ended interpretation. The poem feels like a whispered secret, or perhaps a confession, creating an intimate relationship between the reader and the speaker.

"Doppelganger" critically engages with the human condition, forcing us to confront the double-edged sword that is our ability to choose. By making decisions, we are also crafting our emotional landscapes, carving out spaces of both commitment and loss. And it is in this carving, this endless cleaving, that we are most deeply human. With every cut, we are shaped, and our "doppelgangers" are born, challenging us to navigate the "steep woods" of our lives with awareness and perhaps a touch of sorrow for the paths forever closed to us.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...