Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

Claude McKay's poem "Killin' Nanny" is a poignant exploration of innocence, cruelty, and the shaping of human nature through early experiences. The poem tells the story of two young children witnessing the slaughter of a goat, a seemingly simple yet profound event that offers insight into the divergent paths they will take as they grow older. Through vivid imagery and the use of Jamaican patois, McKay presents a powerful narrative about the loss of innocence and the development of moral character.

The poem begins with a scene of two "little pickny," or small children, watching as a goat, referred to as "Nanny," is led to its death. The children are described as being "little ones of two years," emphasizing their youth and the innocence that comes with it. At this tender age, they are unaware of the concept of "badness" or cruelty. This innocence sets the stage for the contrast that will emerge as the poem progresses.

As the butcher prepares to kill the goat, "Nanny" cries out for mercy ("bawlin' fe mussy"). The children's reactions to the slaughter are notably different. One child, overwhelmed by the sight of the goat's suffering and the flow of its blood, trembles and hides his face in his mother's bosom. This reaction suggests a sensitivity and compassion that will likely influence the child's future behavior.

In contrast, the other child watches the scene with wide eyes, seemingly fascinated by the violence. This child does not flinch or look away but instead stares with "joy," clapping his hands with glee as the goat is killed. This reaction is chilling, indicating an early attraction to violence or a lack of empathy that foreshadows a darker path.

The poem then shifts forward in time, revealing the fates of the two children as they grow into men. The one who had cried at the sight of Nanny's death seems to have maintained his sensitivity, while the child who watched with joy has become marked by his early fascination with cruelty. McKay uses the powerful Biblical allusion to the "mark of Cain" to describe the man who once clapped in glee. In the Bible, Cain is the first murderer, marked by God as a warning to others. This mark signifies not only guilt but also the inherent violence that has become a part of this man's identity.

The poem's narrative is a reflection on how early experiences can shape a person's moral compass. The act of witnessing violence can either instill a deep sense of empathy and horror or, conversely, desensitize and even delight, leading to a future marked by cruelty. McKay's use of the "mark of Cain" emphasizes the irreversible nature of this moral divergence.

"Killin' Nanny" also engages with broader themes of innocence, experience, and the loss of childhood purity. The children's reactions to the goat's death serve as a metaphor for the ways in which people can become hardened or corrupted by the harsh realities of life. The poem suggests that the seeds of violence and cruelty can be planted early and that these seeds can grow into defining aspects of one's character.

Through his use of dialect and vivid storytelling, McKay creates a narrative that is both culturally specific and universally resonant. The poem invites readers to reflect on the ways in which individuals respond to the suffering of others and how these responses can shape their futures. "Killin' Nanny" is a powerful meditation on the nature of innocence, the impact of early experiences, and the potential for both compassion and cruelty within the human heart.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...