Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

The poem "Variation on a Line by Emerson" by William Stanley Merwin invites the reader into a complex and nuanced meditation on time, solitude, and the transience of emotions. Merwin, a renowned American poet, often focused on themes of loss, memory, and nature, and this poem serves as an elegant representation of these preoccupations. As the title suggests, this piece is a variation on a line by Ralph Waldo Emerson, an American transcendentalist poet and essayist, and it draws upon Emerson's characteristic exploration of the spiritual significance of nature.

The opening stanza introduces the seasonality of human emotions and experiences: "In May, when sea-winds pierced our solitudes, / In the May winds not yet warmed out of malice." Here, Merwin juxtaposes the temporality of May winds-themselves fluctuating between warmth and chill-with human solitude and the lingering trace of "malice." The winds become a metaphor for the unpredictable yet inescapable ebb and flow of human emotions.

The speaker then delves into a specific memory: "At a certain doorway once I stood, my face / Leaning westward, a little before evening." The precision of this moment, leaning westward toward the setting sun, suggests an acute awareness of the passing of time, an ephemeral moment trapped in memory. This theme continues as the speaker rhetorically asks, "Oh, though all breath be seasonal, who can tell / A story like new grass blown in sunlight?" Here, the poem emphasizes the irreplaceability and uniqueness of individual experiences. Like new grass in sunlight, each moment has its singular beauty, impossible to replicate or describe fully.

Merwin uses repetition to contrast the impact of time on experience. The repeated mention of "May," "solitudes," "evening," and "malice" in varying contexts demonstrates how different moments, despite their similarities, can never be the same. This adds to the poem's complexity, as it underscores the unpredictability and changeability of life and emotions.

The speaker's tone turns somber in the concluding lines: "You that have forsaken the door, the face, / Burgeon, body, decrease, the turning light." Here, forsaken elements-whether physical or metaphorical-point to loss, and "turning light" captures the cyclical yet irrevocable passage of time. The poem ends on a note of existential uncertainty: "Whether the bodily death is death to malice / Not the intrusions of sea-wind tell." Here, the speaker questions the ultimate transformation-death-and wonders if it carries the power to extinguish human vices like malice.

William Stanley Merwin's "Variation on a Line by Emerson" serves as both homage and interrogation. While it starts from Emerson's transcendentalist preoccupations, it proceeds to forge its own path of inquiry into the human condition. Rich in metaphor and lush imagery, the poem reflects the complexities of solitude, the evanescence of time, and the ever-changing landscape of human emotions. These themes are set against a backdrop of natural elements-winds, light, and sea-that lend the poem both its texture and depth, making it a compelling piece that resonates across multiple dimensions of human experience.

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...