Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained

In "Origin," Howard Nemerov offers a whimsical yet profound exploration of the beginnings of language. The poem’s simplicity belies a deeper reflection on the collaborative and mysterious nature of human communication. Through a dialogue with the dead, Nemerov invites readers to ponder the origins of language and its fundamental role in human connection.

The poem begins with a journey into the past: "I went way back and asked the old / Ones deep in the graves, the youngest dead." This opening line sets a mythical and contemplative tone, suggesting a search for ancient wisdom buried in the collective memory of humanity. The phrase "the youngest dead" hints at a timeless source of knowledge, where even the recently deceased possess insights from a distant past.

The speaker’s inquiry—"how language began, and who had the credit / of it, gods, men, devils, elves?"—lists various potential origins of language, encompassing divine, human, and mythological sources. This range of possibilities reflects the complexity and mystery surrounding the creation of language, a fundamental aspect of human culture and identity. By including "gods, men, devils, elves," Nemerov acknowledges both rational and fantastical explanations, highlighting the enigma of language's birth.

The response from the dead is striking in its simplicity and collective nature: "We got together one day," they said, / "And talked it over among ourselves." This answer suggests that language arose from a communal and consensual process, emphasizing the social aspect of linguistic development. The idea that language emerged from people coming together and communicating reinforces the notion that language is inherently a product of human interaction and cooperation.

Nemerov’s use of direct speech from the dead adds a layer of authenticity and immediacy to their response, as if the answer is a straightforward truth passed down through the ages. The casual tone of "talked it over among ourselves" contrasts with the profound nature of the question, adding a touch of humor and humility to the narrative. This contrast underscores the idea that the origins of language, while deeply significant, might also be rooted in the everyday act of people simply coming together to communicate.

The poem’s structure is concise and unembellished, mirroring the clarity and brevity of the answer provided. Nemerov’s choice of plain language and straightforward narrative enhances the accessibility of the poem, inviting readers to reflect on the shared human experience of language without the distraction of complex literary devices.

"Origin" by Howard Nemerov is a contemplative and insightful meditation on the beginnings of language. Through its simple yet profound narrative, the poem suggests that language is a communal creation, born from the inherent human need to connect and communicate. By attributing the origin of language to a collective decision-making process, Nemerov emphasizes the social nature of linguistic development and the shared responsibility of all who speak. The poem encourages readers to appreciate the fundamental role of language in human society and to consider the enduring mystery of how it all began.

Copyright (c) 2025 PoetryExplorer

Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!

Other Poems of Interest...