![]() |
Classic and Contemporary Poetry: Explained | |||
Alan Shapiro’s "Virgil’s Descent" is a profound meditation on exile, denial, and the painful intersection of mythic and historical suffering. The poem reframes Virgil—Dante’s pagan guide in The Divine Comedy—as a figure akin to Tantalus, perpetually denied the grace he can see but never receive. By linking Virgil’s unworthiness for salvation to the horrors of the Holocaust, Shapiro extends the poem’s meditation on exclusion, turning it into a broader indictment of historical and divine justice. The poem’s structure, imagery, and allusions create a layered narrative in which Virgil’s descent is not just through Dante’s Hell but through the moral abyss of the twentieth century. The poem opens with a striking comparison: "Not Moses but another Tantalus— / to have been granted this much, and no more: / to see beyond the stream he?d never cross." This immediately sets up Virgil as a tragic figure, forever outside the realm of divine favor. Tantalus, in Greek mythology, was doomed to stand in water that receded whenever he tried to drink and beneath fruit that remained out of reach—an eternal state of torment. Virgil’s fate is similar: he can see "the gift he was not chosen for," but he remains on the far shore, unworthy of entering paradise. The reference to Moses complicates this exile—Moses, though never allowed to enter the Promised Land, was still chosen by God. Virgil, by contrast, is excluded entirely from divine grace, not just denied a destination but removed from salvation’s structure altogether. Virgil’s only solace is that he can descend "slowly enough to see its radiance shine / dim and dimmer in the rising eyes he sinks past." The fading light mirrors his loss of proximity to the divine, reinforcing the sorrow of witnessing grace without being able to possess it. The phrase "a darkening penitence" suggests that his descent is itself an act of submission, though one that offers no possibility of redemption. The paradox of "the fire that scorches till he dies / of being unsinged" captures Virgil’s ultimate torment: he is not even allowed to suffer in the way the damned do. His punishment is exclusion, an absence of both salvation and damnation. The following lines introduce a jarring movement—where Dante?s sinners ascend toward their punishments, "Upward forever, the flayed gluttons, whores, / killers and con men to their just reward, / all jostling by him in a holy mesh." The idea of the damned ascending toward suffering in "a holy mesh" is deeply ironic. Justice, as it exists in Dante’s vision, is made to seem mechanistic, indifferent. Virgil, meanwhile, is caught between these movements, a mere observer who can "study, and repeat, and never master" the divine structure of judgment. Then, suddenly, the scene shifts from the allegorical to the historical: "Now they deboard: / the naked cargo of a new disaster, / women and children, Gypsy, Slav, and Jew, / their charred flesh smoking out of every boxcar." This turn is shocking in its abruptness. The poem moves from Virgil’s mythic exile to the reality of the Holocaust, forcing the reader to confront the inadequacy of theological structures in the face of modern atrocity. The people emerging from the boxcars are spectral, "eerily in the steam they wade out through." They have already been reduced to the status of the dead, moving like souls through Dante’s underworld, though their suffering is entirely of human making. The most chilling moment comes in the line: "half-afraid / they?re not arriving, but returning to." This suggests that history is cyclical, that these victims, rather than being met with deliverance, are being sent back into suffering. It also implies an existential horror—that perhaps there is no true death, only recurrence, an endless reenactment of trauma. The scrambling prisoners seek "the prayed-for dark," but there is no escape from the "wandering aura"—perhaps the divine light, perhaps the lingering trace of what has happened. Virgil’s role in this vision becomes increasingly fraught: "never more hopeless, never less assuaged, / he sings, he sings about the burning sphere / love not meant for them." He continues to perform his role as poet, singing of the divine radiance, but his song now carries a deep cruelty. What was once an act of artful praise becomes an act of erasure, an aestheticization of suffering that does nothing to save those whose pain it describes. The phrase "whose burning fueled / another kind of transport straight to here" conflates the divine fire with the literal burning of human bodies, exposing the horrific irony of spiritual transcendence when measured against historical genocide. The final section intensifies Virgil’s torment: "The more he sings, the more the song seems cruel, / and more mysterious, the merciful bright / manna on his tongue becoming gruel." His words, which once might have held meaning, are now hollow. The manna—a biblical symbol of divine sustenance—degenerates into "gruel," something thin, meager, and unsatisfying. His poetry no longer nourishes; it only prolongs the agony of understanding without salvation. The last image in the poem is one of dispersal: "endlessly in and out of one another / over the floor of that vast terminal / the way birds at a sudden shot will scatter / to far trees, and beyond them, as if they could hear / the sharp blast echoing forever, / and nowhere could be far enough away." The Holocaust victims move like flocks of birds, reacting to a violence that will not cease, to an echoing that has no endpoint. The idea that "nowhere could be far enough away" suggests the inescapability of history, the way trauma persists beyond time and space. Virgil’s Descent is a searing confrontation with exclusion—of the unbaptized poet from heaven, of the Holocaust’s victims from humanity, and of art’s powerlessness in the face of suffering. By weaving Dantean imagery with historical atrocity, Shapiro forces us to question the justice of divine order and the adequacy of poetry as a response to human horror. Virgil, once Dante’s guide, becomes the guide to a different kind of underworld—one where history, rather than theology, dictates the terms of damnation. And in this descent, there is no salvation, only the unbearable recognition of what cannot be undone.
| Discover our Poem Explanations and Poet Analyses!Other Poems of Interest...A SUNRISE SONG by SIDNEY LANIER URANIA; THE WOMAN IN THE MOON: THE SECOND CANTO, OR FIRST QUARTER by WILLIAM BASSE LOVES ADVENTURE by JOSEPH BEAUMONT FRAGMENTS INTENDED FOR DEATH'S JEST-BOOK: SORROW by THOMAS LOVELL BEDDOES MILLCREEK by MATTIE-LOU BLACKWOOD A PERFECT SONNET by WILFRID SCAWEN BLUNT ENVY; A FRAGMENT by JANE BOWDLER |
|